Is $x^x=y$ solvable for $x$?

4k Views Asked by At

Given that

  1. $x^x = y$; and
  2. given some value for $y$

is there a way to expressly solve that equation for $x$?

3

There are 3 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

As Aryabhata mentions this is another application for the Lambert W function. The solution to your problem is presented in the wikipedia article. Using elementary substitutions you have

$$x=\frac{\ln(y)}{W(\ln y)}$$

If you are interested in the asymptotic growth of $x$ relative to $y$, note that for every $z$: $W(z) = \ln{z} - \ln\ln{z} + o(1)$. Hence:

$$x=\frac{\ln(y)}{\ln{\ln y} - \ln\ln{\ln y} + o(1)} = \Theta\left( \frac{\ln y}{\ln \ln y}\right)$$

3
On

You should try WolframAlpha for similar problems. WolframAlpha would solve y=x^x for y=5 as shown here (using Lamber W Function as suggested before).

0
On

Given y, you can solve y = x**x with a simple iteration:

  1. Set x_0 = 2 (or anything else really)
  2. x_(i+1) = ln y / ln x_i
  3. Repeat 2 until abs(x_(i+1) - x_i) < threshold

It's akin to Newton's method of finding square roots.

The convergence of this process is the "natural base of y to itself", or the "exponential root" of y.

If you think about this iteration, you're iteratively performing the base-change logarithm formula. So at first you get y's logarithm (or "bit length") in base 2. Then in base of what y was in base 2, and so on. Successive values oscillate around the "natural base of y to itself" until it converges.

It's pretty interesting. I wonder if there's anything special about the value of x for each y.

As other people have said, you can take log of each side, to get:

ln y = ln x**x, which is ln y = x ln x, and the iteration