Locus of center of an elliptical disc tangent to the coordinate planes

44 Views Asked by At

An elliptical disc of semi-major axis $a$ and semi-minor axis $b$ is placed in the corner of the first octant (where $x \ge 0, y \ge 0, z \ge 0$), such that it is tangent to the $xy, xz$ and $yz$ planes. Find the locus of the center of the disc as its normal vector sweeps all possible orientations.

enter image description here

My Attempt:

Points on the perimeter of the disc can be parameterized as

$ r(t) = r_C + a \cos t \ u_1 + b \sin t \ u_2 $

where $u_1, u_2$ are two mutually orthogonal unit vectors that are orthogonal to $n$, the unit normal vector to the plane of the disc. $u_1$ is along the major axis and $u_2$ is along the minor axis of the elliptical disc. And,

$ r_C = (x_C, y_C, z_C) $

is the center of the disc.

At tangency with the $xy$ plane, we have

$ 0 = z_C + a \cos t_1 \ u_{1z} + b \sin t_1 \ u_{2z} $

For some $t_1 \in [0, 2 \pi) $.

And by setting the $z$ coordinate of the tangent vector to $r$ (which is $r'$) to $0$, we get

$ 0 = - a \sin t_1 \ u_{1z} + b \cos t_1 \ u_{2z} $

Simple algebraic manipulation leads to

$z_C = \sqrt{ a^2 u_{1z}^2 + b^2 u_{2z}^2 } $

Similar formulas apply for $x_C $ and $y_C$, namely,

$x_C = \sqrt{ a^2 u_{1x}^2 + b^2 u_{2x}^2 } $

$y_C = \sqrt{ a^2 u_{1y}^2 + b^2 u_{2y}^2 } $

Squaring $x_C, y_C , z_C $ and adding yields

$ x_C^2 + y_C^2 + z_C^2 = a^2 (u_{1x}^2 + u_{1y}^2 + u_{1z}^2) + b^2 (u_{2x}^2 + u_{2y}^2 + u_{2z}^2 ) $

But $u_1$ and $u_2$ are unit vectors, therefore, the above simplifies to

$ x_C^2 + y_C^2 + z_C^2 = a^2 + b^2 $

Thus the center of the disc lies on a sphere centered at the origin with radius equal to $\sqrt{a^2 + b^2} $.

My Question:

I am looking for a confirmation of the above analysis. Alternative solutions or comments are highly appreciated. Thanks to all.