Maclane/Birkhoff's "Algebra" as a first book on the subject?

Question

Would the more knowledgeable and well-versed members of this community be so helpful as to give their opinion on using Birkhoff & MacLane's famous "Algebra" for a first course in Abstract Algebra? Would it be a good introduction to the subject? Would it be suitable for self-study?

Obviously, the answers are bound to be highly personal. But knowing what others have to say sure makes it easier to commit to a book (and, by extension, the price tag attached to said book). Especially considering Herstein, Dummitt & Foote, Artin and others are considerably more expensive.

Answer 1

"Algebra" by MacLane and Birkhoff was the first abstract algebra book I bought and I loved it!

It wasn't the first abstract algebra book I read, though, but it probably was the first book that I read carefully.

I recommend "Algebra" for self study at your leisure. It will teach you undergraduate abstract algebra while introducing you to categorical ideas, especially the role of universals. Highly recommended.

It could probably work for teaching a first course to students who have never seen abstract algebra, if the instructor is at ease with it.

Answer 2

I am definitely not well-versed or knowledgeable on the subject. I have however tried to read many algebra books. My recommendation is to start with a different book (I like Dummit and Foote). Preferably one that does not use category theory, unless you are a genius this will probably save you from a lot of suffering.