Mistake in my proof: what is the normalisation factor of the surface integral of a sphere?

84 Views Asked by At

I was trying to prove

$$ {1\over \varepsilon} \int_{\partial B(a,\varepsilon)} f dS = {1\over r} \int_{\partial B(a,r)} f dS$$

where $0<\varepsilon < r$ and $f$ is harmonic on $\mathbb R^2$ and $n$ is the normal vector to the sphere.

Here is what I did:

(0) I use the equation $$ \int_{D}(f\Delta g - g \Delta f)dV = \int_{\partial D}\left( f {\partial g \over \partial n} - g {\partial f \over \partial n}\right) dS$$ and let $g(x) = \log \|x-a\|$. (this is a radial harmonic function)

(1) I calculated that ${\partial g \over \partial n} = 1$ (this is probably correct, I suspect my mistake to be later in the calculation)

(2) I note that $\int_{B(a,r) \setminus B(a,\varepsilon)} (f \Delta G - G \Delta f)dV = 0$ because both $f$ and $g$ are harmonic

(3) I showed that $$ \int_{\partial B(a,r)} g {\partial f \over \partial n} dS = 0$$

(4) I put (1)-(3) together so that

$$ 0 = \int_{B(a,r) \setminus B(a,\varepsilon)} (f \Delta G - G \Delta f)dV = \int_{\partial B(a,r) \sqcup \partial B(a,\varepsilon)} f dS$$

But this results in

$$ \int_{\partial B(a,\varepsilon)} f dS = \int_{\partial B(a,r)} f dS$$

and there is one problem with that:

I am missing the factors of ${1\over \varepsilon}$ and ${1\over r}$.

Hence my question is:

How can I calculate the normalisation of the surface integral of the sphere?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

5
On BEST ANSWER

(4) I put (1)-(3) together so that $$ 0 = \int_{B(a,r) \setminus B(a,\varepsilon)} (f \Delta G - G \Delta f)\, dV = \int_{\partial B(a,r) \sqcup \partial B(a,\varepsilon)} f\, dS $$

It appears you've lost the normal derivative of $g$. That is, the right-hand integral should be $$ 0 = \int_{B(a,r) \setminus B(a,\varepsilon)} (f \Delta G - G \Delta f)\, dV = \int_{\partial B(a,r) \sqcup \partial B(a,\varepsilon)} f \frac{\partial g}{\partial n}\, dS, $$ and of course $\dfrac{\partial g}{\partial n}(x) = \dfrac{1}{\|x - a\|}$.