Non-pythagorean triples

786 Views Asked by At

Euclid's formula gives a recipe for generating all possible Pythagorean triples $a^2+b^2 = c^2$ exactly once; for set of positive integers $k$ and $m>n$ ($m$ relatively prime to $n$, exactly one of $m$ and $n$ odd), define

$$a=k(m^2-n^2)\qquad b= k(2mn)\qquad c=k(m^2+n^2).$$

I am wondering if we can derive a similar simple parameterized formula for enumerating a set of non-pythagorean triples of the form $$a^2 +Qab + b^2 = c^2$$

for all $a,b,c\in\mathbb{N}$ and $Q$ is an integer fixed in advance? I've tried applying various proofs of Euclid's formula to derive a similar result, with no success. (If relevant, the value $Q=14$ is especially salient for my current application, and the values $Q=\pm 2$ seem to have an especially straightforward solution.)

3

There are 3 best solutions below

10
On

Consider the curve $C$ defined by the equation $x^{2}+Qxy+y^{2}=1$ and a line $y=k(x+1)$ with $k\in \mathbb{Q}$. If the graph of $C$ (ellipse or hyperbola, for $Q\neq \pm 2$) intersects with the second line at two points, those points are given by $$ (-1, 0), \quad \left (\frac{1-k^{2}}{1+Qk+k^{2}}, \frac{2k+Qk^{2}}{1+Qk+k^{2}}\right) $$ and this gives a rational points on the curve $C$. Also, you can easily check that every rational points can be obtained by this way, except for $(-1, Q)$, which corresponds to $k=\infty$. Using this parametrization, we can prove that every solution of the Diophantine equation $a^{2}+Qab+b^{2}=c^{2}$ are given by $$ (a, b, c) = (m^{2}-n^{2}, 2mn+Qn^{2}, m^{2}+Qmn+n^{2}). $$


As other people mentioned, it doesn't give all solutions, but it can give all primitive solutions. For example, if $(a, b, c)$ is a primitive solution of the equation, i.e. $\gcd(a, b, c)=1$, then $$ k=\frac{b}{a+c} $$ gives the corresponding rational point $$ \left(\frac{a}{c}, \frac{b}{c}\right) $$ on $C$, and the solution $$ ((a+c)^{2}-b^{2}, 2b(a+c)+Qb^{2}, (a+c)^{2}+Qb(a+c)+b^{2}) $$ which is a (possibly) non-primitive solution parallel to the original solution $(a, b, c)$. Conversely, every primitive solution can be obtained by $$ \frac{1}{d}(m^{2}-n^{2}, 2mn+Qn^{2}, m^{2}+Qmn+n^{2}) $$ where $d$ is a gcd of each components. If you don't want this kind of treatment, I think Will Jagy's answer is more appropriate.

3
On

$$ a = u^2 - 4uv+3v^2, \; \; b = u^2 + 4uv+3v^2, \; \; c = 4 u^2 - 12 v^2 \; \; ,$$ $$ a = 3u^2 - 14uv+16v^2, \; \; b = 2uv, \; \; c = 3 u^2 - 16 v^2 \; \; ,$$ $$ a = u^2 - 14uv+48v^2, \; \; b = 2uv, \; \; c = u^2 - 48 v^2 \; \; .$$

The first triple comes from $$ \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 1 & 1 & 4 \\ -4 & 4 & 0 \\ 3 & 3 & -12 \end{array} \right) \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 1 & 7 & 0 \\ 7 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & -1 \end{array} \right) \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 1 & -4 & 3 \\ 1 & 4 & 3 \\ 4 & 0 & -12 \end{array} \right) = 96 \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 0 & 0 & 1 \\ 0 & -2 & 0 \\ 1 & 0 & 0 \end{array} \right) $$ Notice that the final matrix is the Hessian matrix of $xz-y^2.$ Furthermore, the primitive solutions to $xy-z^2 = 0$ with at least one of $x,z$ positive are of the form $$ x = u^2, \; \; y = u v , \; \; z = v^2. $$ If you put that as a column vector on the right of the matirx, and on the left as a row vector, you get zero. But the matrix identity then says that............... $$ \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 3 & 0 & 3 \\ -14 & 2 & 0 \\ 16 & 0 & -16 \end{array} \right) \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 1 & 7 & 0 \\ 7 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & -1 \end{array} \right) \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 3 & -14 & 16 \\ 0 & 2 & 0 \\ 3 & 0 & -16 \end{array} \right) = 96 \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 0 & 0 & 1 \\ 0 & -2 & 0 \\ 1 & 0 & 0 \end{array} \right) $$

$$ \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 1 & 0 & 1 \\ -14 & 2 & 0 \\ 48 & 0 & -48 \end{array} \right) \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 1 & 7 & 0 \\ 7 & 1 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & -1 \end{array} \right) \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 1 & -14 & 48 \\ 0 & 2 & 0 \\ 1 & 0 & -48 \end{array} \right) = 96 \left( \begin{array}{rrr} 0 & 0 & 1 \\ 0 & -2 & 0 \\ 1 & 0 & 0 \end{array} \right) $$

If you want to have non-primitive solutions, and perhaps all positive, take $u,v \geq 0,$ $\gcd(u,v)=1,$ use all three recipes above and keep the triples where $a,b > 0$ and $\gcd(a,b,c) = 1,$ then take $k \geq 1$ and triples $ \left( ka, \; kb, \; k|c| \right) \; .$

The general setup of Fricke and Klein (1897) says that a finite number of such recipes give all primitive integer solutions.

working. these are the primitive integer $a \geq b > 0,$ $a \leq 100,$ $a^2 + 14 ab + b^2 = c^2$

 1         1         4
 5         2        13
 6         1        11
10         3        23
12         7        37
21         5        44
21        10        59
22        15        73
28        15        83
35         2        47
35         3        52
35        26       121
39         4        61
44         5        71
45        28       143
51        40       181
55         7        92
55        36       179
56        11       109
65        14       131
65        33       188
68         5        97
70        57       253
76        21       169
77        20       167
78        55       263
88         3       107
90        13       157
91        66       311
92        77       337
99        34       241
99        35       244

Not bad in what follows. Still missing those with $a,b$ both odd.

Got them.

   int a =   u* u +4 *  u * v + 3 * v * v;
   int b =   u* u -4 *  u * v + 3 * v * v;
   int c =  4* u* u  - 12 * v * v;
      1      1      4   u v       1      0
     21      5    -44   u v       1      2
     35      3     52   u v       4      1
     55      7    -92   u v       2      3
     65     33   -188   u v       1      4
     99     35    244   u v       8      1

=======================================

=================================================

first alternate formula, Just take the absolute value of $c$

   int a = 3 * u* u - 14 * u * v + 16 * v * v;
   int b = 2 * u * v;
   int c = 3 * u * u - 16 * v * v;

  5      2    -13   u v       1      1
  6      1     11   u v       3      1
 12      7    -37   u v       3      2
 21     10     59   u v       5      1
 28     15     83   u v       7      2
 39      4    -61   u v       1      2
 51     40   -181   u v       5      4
 55     36    179   u v       9      2
 56     11   -109   u v       7      4
 65     14    131   u v       7      1
 70     57   -253   u v       7      5
 88      3    107   u v      11      4
 90     13   -157   u v       9      5

=================================================

original formula, in essence

  int a =   u* u - 14 * u * v + 48 * v * v;
   int b = 2 * u * v;
   int c =  u * u - 48 * v * v;

      10      3    -23   u v       5      1
     22     15     73   u v      11      1
     35      2    -47   u v       1      1
     35     26    121   u v      13      1
     44      5    -71   u v      11      2
     45     28   -143   u v       7      2
     68      5     97   u v      17      2
     76     21    169   u v      19      2
     77     20   -167   u v       5      2
     78     55   -263   u v      13      3
     91     66   -311   u v      11      3
     92     77    337   u v      23      2
     99     34    241   u v      17      1

=============================================

0
On

$$ a = u^2 - 4uv+3v^2, \; \; b = u^2 + 4uv+3v^2, \; \; c = 4 u^2 - 12 v^2 \; \; ,$$ $$ a = 3u^2 - 14uv+16v^2, \; \; b = 2uv, \; \; c = 3 u^2 - 16 v^2 \; \; ,$$ $$ a = u^2 - 14uv+48v^2, \; \; b = 2uv, \; \; c = u^2 - 48 v^2 \; \; .$$

  1      1      4   u v       1      0 : 4,0,-12  
  5      2    -13   u v       1      1 : 3,0,-16  
  6      1     11   u v       3      1 : 3,0,-16  
 10      3    -23   u v       5      1 : 1,0,-48  
 12      7    -37   u v       3      2 : 3,0,-16  
 21     10     59   u v       5      1 : 3,0,-16  
 21      5    -44   u v       1      2 : 4,0,-12  
 22     15     73   u v      11      1 : 1,0,-48  
 28     15     83   u v       7      2 : 3,0,-16  
 35      2    -47   u v       1      1 : 1,0,-48  
 35     26    121   u v      13      1 : 1,0,-48  
 35      3     52   u v       4      1 : 4,0,-12  
 39      4    -61   u v       1      2 : 3,0,-16  
 44      5    -71   u v      11      2 : 1,0,-48  
 45     28   -143   u v       7      2 : 1,0,-48  
 51     40   -181   u v       5      4 : 3,0,-16  
 55     36    179   u v       9      2 : 3,0,-16  
 55      7    -92   u v       2      3 : 4,0,-12  
 56     11   -109   u v       7      4 : 3,0,-16  
 65     14    131   u v       7      1 : 3,0,-16  
 65     33   -188   u v       1      4 : 4,0,-12  
 68      5     97   u v      17      2 : 1,0,-48  
 70     57   -253   u v       7      5 : 3,0,-16  
 76     21    169   u v      19      2 : 1,0,-48  
 77     20   -167   u v       5      2 : 1,0,-48  
 78     55   -263   u v      13      3 : 1,0,-48  
 88      3    107   u v      11      4 : 3,0,-16  
 90     13   -157   u v       9      5 : 3,0,-16  
 91     66   -311   u v      11      3 : 1,0,-48  
 92     77    337   u v      23      2 : 1,0,-48  
 99     34    241   u v      17      1 : 1,0,-48  
 99     35    244   u v       8      1 : 4,0,-12  
102      7   -143   u v      17      3 : 1,0,-48  
104     35    251   u v      13      4 : 3,0,-16  
115     24   -229   u v       3      4 : 3,0,-16  
117    100    433   u v      25      2 : 1,0,-48  
117      5    148   u v       7      2 : 4,0,-12  
119     39   -284   u v       2      5 : 4,0,-12  
119     44    299   u v      11      2 : 3,0,-16  
120     91    419   u v      15      4 : 3,0,-16  
133     18    227   u v       9      1 : 3,0,-16  
133     85   -428   u v       1      6 : 4,0,-12  
136    105   -479   u v      17      4 : 1,0,-48  
143     38    313   u v      19      1 : 1,0,-48  
143     63    388   u v      10      1 : 4,0,-12  
145    126   -541   u v       9      7 : 3,0,-16  
150      7    193   u v      25      3 : 1,0,-48  
152     65   -407   u v      19      4 : 1,0,-48  
154     69   -421   u v      11      7 : 3,0,-16  
165      4   -191   u v       1      2 : 1,0,-48  
170     77    467   u v      17      5 : 3,0,-16  
171     11   -236   u v       4      5 : 4,0,-12  
171    136    611   u v      17      4 : 3,0,-16  
174     55    409   u v      29      3 : 1,0,-48  
176    155   -661   u v      11      8 : 3,0,-16  
182     17   -277   u v      13      7 : 3,0,-16  
184      9   -239   u v      23      4 : 1,0,-48  
186     91    529   u v      31      3 : 1,0,-48  
187     42   -383   u v       7      3 : 1,0,-48  
190    153    683   u v      19      5 : 3,0,-16  
203      8   -253   u v       1      4 : 3,0,-16  
207     52    443   u v      13      2 : 3,0,-16  
207     95   -572   u v       2      7 : 4,0,-12  
208     75   -517   u v      13      8 : 3,0,-16  
209    104   -599   u v      13      4 : 1,0,-48  
210    187    793   u v      35      3 : 1,0,-48  
217     30   -373   u v       3      5 : 3,0,-16  
221    116    649   u v      29      2 : 1,0,-48  
221     45    436   u v      11      2 : 4,0,-12  
225    161   -764   u v       1      8 : 4,0,-12  
225     22    347   u v      11      1 : 3,0,-16  
230    119   -671   u v      23      5 : 1,0,-48  
231    190   -839   u v      19      5 : 1,0,-48  
240     19   -349   u v      15      8 : 3,0,-16  
247    222    937   u v      37      3 : 1,0,-48  
247     30   -407   u v       5      3 : 1,0,-48  
247      7    292   u v      10      3 : 4,0,-12  
253     13   -332   u v       5      6 : 4,0,-12  
253    210    923   u v      21      5 : 3,0,-16  
255    143    772   u v      14      1 : 4,0,-12  
255     46    481   u v      23      1 : 1,0,-48  
259    144   -781   u v       9      8 : 3,0,-16  
266      5    299   u v      19      7 : 3,0,-16  
273     88   -647   u v      11      4 : 1,0,-48  
275    152    827   u v      19      4 : 3,0,-16  
275     51   -524   u v       4      7 : 4,0,-12  
280     33    457   u v      35      4 : 1,0,-48  
285    124    769   u v      31      2 : 1,0,-48  
285     77    628   u v      13      2 : 4,0,-12  
287    260  -1093   u v      13     10 : 3,0,-16  
290     11   -359   u v      29      5 : 1,0,-48  
296     65    601   u v      37      4 : 1,0,-48  
299    170   -911   u v      17      5 : 1,0,-48  
300    253  -1103   u v      25      6 : 1,0,-48  
319    175   -956   u v       2      9 : 4,0,-12  
319     60    611   u v      15      2 : 3,0,-16  
322    117    803   u v      23      7 : 3,0,-16  
323    195   1012   u v      16      1 : 4,0,-12  
323     50    577   u v      25      1 : 1,0,-48  
325    276  -1199   u v      23      6 : 1,0,-48  
328    153    913   u v      41      4 : 1,0,-48  
330    301  -1261   u v      15     11 : 3,0,-16  
333     10   -397   u v       1      5 : 3,0,-16  
340     87   -733   u v      17     10 : 3,0,-16  
341    261  -1196   u v       1     10 : 4,0,-12  
341     26    491   u v      13      1 : 3,0,-16  
344    209   1081   u v      43      4 : 1,0,-48  
348    133   -887   u v      29      6 : 1,0,-48  
350    209   1091   u v      25      7 : 3,0,-16  
368     35    563   u v      23      8 : 3,0,-16  
369     70   -709   u v       5      7 : 3,0,-16  
372     85   -767   u v      31      6 : 1,0,-48  
374    185  -1069   u v      17     11 : 3,0,-16  
376    345   1441   u v      47      4 : 1,0,-48  
377    230   1187   u v      23      5 : 3,0,-16  
377     57   -668   u v       5      8 : 4,0,-12  
378    325   1403   u v      27      7 : 3,0,-16  
380     23   -517   u v      19     10 : 3,0,-16  
387    112   -877   u v       7      8 : 3,0,-16  
391    246   1249   u v      41      3 : 1,0,-48  
391     55    676   u v      14      3 : 4,0,-12  
391      6   -431   u v       1      3 : 1,0,-48  
400     99    851   u v      25      8 : 3,0,-16  
403    115   -908   u v       4      9 : 4,0,-12  
403    168   1067   u v      21      4 : 3,0,-16  
406    351  -1511   u v      29      7 : 1,0,-48  
410     11    481   u v      41      5 : 1,0,-48  
418     93   -853   u v      19     11 : 3,0,-16  
420     13   -503   u v      35      6 : 1,0,-48  
423    220  -1237   u v      11     10 : 3,0,-16  
425    392   1633   u v      49      4 : 1,0,-48  
425     56   -719   u v       7      4 : 1,0,-48  
425      9    484   u v      13      4 : 4,0,-12  
430     39    649   u v      43      5 : 1,0,-48  
432    187   1163   u v      27      8 : 3,0,-16  
434    275  -1391   u v      31      7 : 1,0,-48  
437    140   1033   u v      35      2 : 1,0,-48  
437    165   1108   u v      17      2 : 4,0,-12  
441    286  -1429   u v      13     11 : 3,0,-16  
455    279  -1436   u v       2     11 : 4,0,-12  
455     68    803   u v      17      2 : 3,0,-16  
459    130  -1031   u v      13      5 : 1,0,-48  
462     25   -613   u v      21     11 : 3,0,-16  
464    299   1499   u v      29      8 : 3,0,-16  
465     17   -572   u v       7      8 : 4,0,-12  
465    406   1739   u v      29      7 : 3,0,-16  
470    119   1009   u v      47      5 : 1,0,-48  
475    258   1417   u v      43      3 : 1,0,-48  
475     91    916   u v      16      3 : 4,0,-12  
477    442  -1837   u v      17     13 : 3,0,-16  
481     30    659   u v      15      1 : 3,0,-16  
481    385  -1724   u v       1     12 : 4,0,-12  
483    323   1588   u v      20      1 : 4,0,-12  
483     58    793   u v      29      1 : 1,0,-48  
490    171   1201   u v      49      5 : 1,0,-48  
493    228  -1367   u v      19      6 : 1,0,-48  
494    329  -1621   u v      19     13 : 3,0,-16  
496    435   1859   u v      31      8 : 3,0,-16  
513     40   -743   u v       5      4 : 1,0,-48  
517     42   -757   u v       3      7 : 3,0,-16  
518     95   -983   u v      37      7 : 1,0,-48  
525    148   1177   u v      37      2 : 1,0,-48  
525    221   1396   u v      19      2 : 4,0,-12  
527    350  -1727   u v      25      7 : 1,0,-48  
530    299   1609   u v      53      5 : 1,0,-48  
532    495  -2053   u v      19     14 : 3,0,-16  
539     80   -949   u v       5      8 : 3,0,-16  
540      7    587   u v      27     10 : 3,0,-16  
546    205  -1381   u v      21     13 : 3,0,-16  
551    110  -1079   u v      11      5 : 1,0,-48  
555    184   1331   u v      23      4 : 3,0,-16  
555    203  -1388   u v       4     11 : 4,0,-12  
560    377  -1847   u v      35      8 : 1,0,-48  
561    496  -2111   u v      31      8 : 1,0,-48  
574     15   -671   u v      41      7 : 1,0,-48  
575    399   1924   u v      22      1 : 4,0,-12  
575     62    913   u v      31      1 : 1,0,-48  
580     63    923   u v      29     10 : 3,0,-16  
583    180  -1357   u v       9     10 : 3,0,-16  
588     13    673   u v      49      6 : 1,0,-48  
589    204  -1439   u v      17      6 : 1,0,-48  
590    551   2281   u v      59      5 : 1,0,-48  
592    297  -1703   u v      37      8 : 1,0,-48  
595     19   -716   u v       8      9 : 4,0,-12  
595    528   2243   u v      33      8 : 3,0,-16  
598    105  -1117   u v      23     13 : 3,0,-16  
609    424   2041   u v      53      4 : 1,0,-48  
609     65    964   u v      17      4 : 4,0,-12  
615    407  -2012   u v       2     13 : 4,0,-12  
615     76   1019   u v      19      2 : 3,0,-16  
620    143   1283   u v      31     10 : 3,0,-16  
627    322  -1823   u v      23      7 : 1,0,-48  
629    434   2099   u v      31      7 : 3,0,-16  
629     69  -1004   u v       7     10 : 4,0,-12  
636     85   1081   u v      53      6 : 1,0,-48  
644    215  -1549   u v      23     14 : 3,0,-16  
645     34    851   u v      17      1 : 3,0,-16  
645    533  -2348   u v       1     14 : 4,0,-12  
649    390  -2029   u v      15     13 : 3,0,-16  
650     29   -829   u v      25     13 : 3,0,-16  
651     11    724   u v      16      5 : 4,0,-12  
651    610   2521   u v      61      5 : 1,0,-48  
656    161  -1391   u v      41      8 : 1,0,-48  
660    133   1297   u v      55      6 : 1,0,-48  
660    247   1667   u v      33     10 : 3,0,-16  
665    464  -2231   u v      29      8 : 1,0,-48  
666    595  -2519   u v      37      9 : 1,0,-48  
667    187   1492   u v      20      3 : 4,0,-12  
667    282   1777   u v      47      3 : 1,0,-48  
671    476  -2269   u v      17     14 : 3,0,-16  
682     45    947   u v      31     11 : 3,0,-16  
688    105  -1223   u v      43      8 : 1,0,-48  
689     14   -781   u v       1      7 : 3,0,-16  
697    217  -1628   u v       5     12 : 4,0,-12  
697    270   1787   u v      27      5 : 3,0,-16  
700    111  -1261   u v      25     14 : 3,0,-16  
703    630  -2663   u v      35      9 : 1,0,-48  
708    253   1753   u v      59      6 : 1,0,-48  
713    105   1252   u v      19      4 : 4,0,-12  
713    440   2257   u v      55      4 : 1,0,-48  
713      8   -767   u v       1      4 : 1,0,-48  
715     48   -997   u v       3      8 : 3,0,-16  
715    672  -2773   u v      21     16 : 3,0,-16  
725    164   1489   u v      41      2 : 1,0,-48  
725    357   2068   u v      23      2 : 4,0,-12  
731    200   1619   u v      25      4 : 3,0,-16  
731    315  -1964   u v       4     13 : 4,0,-12  
732    325   1993   u v      61      6 : 1,0,-48  
736    531  -2509   u v      23     16 : 3,0,-16  
738    403  -2207   u v      41      9 : 1,0,-48  
740    527   2507   u v      37     10 : 3,0,-16  
752     17   -863   u v      47      8 : 1,0,-48  
756     31   -949   u v      27     14 : 3,0,-16  
759     70  -1151   u v       7      5 : 1,0,-48  
767    140  -1453   u v       7     10 : 3,0,-16  
770    221   1739   u v      35     11 : 3,0,-16  
774    319  -2039   u v      43      9 : 1,0,-48  
775    247   1828   u v      22      3 : 4,0,-12  
775    294   1969   u v      49      3 : 1,0,-48  
779    560   2651   u v      35      8 : 3,0,-16  
779     75  -1196   u v       8     11 : 4,0,-12  
780    493   2497   u v      65      6 : 1,0,-48  
780    703   2963   u v      39     10 : 3,0,-16  
782    737  -3037   u v      23     17 : 3,0,-16  
783    575   2692   u v      26      1 : 4,0,-12  
783     70   1177   u v      35      1 : 1,0,-48  
793    198  -1693   u v       9     11 : 3,0,-16  
799    559  -2684   u v       2     15 : 4,0,-12  
799     84   1259   u v      21      2 : 3,0,-16  
800    371  -2221   u v      25     16 : 3,0,-16  
804    589   2761   u v      67      6 : 1,0,-48  
805    156  -1559   u v      13      6 : 1,0,-48  
814    345   2171   u v      37     11 : 3,0,-16  
817    145  -1532   u v       7     12 : 4,0,-12  
817    462   2483   u v      33      7 : 3,0,-16  
820    741  -3119   u v      41     10 : 1,0,-48  
826     51   1129   u v      59      7 : 1,0,-48  
833     38   1067   u v      19      1 : 3,0,-16  
833    705  -3068   u v       1     16 : 4,0,-12  
837    172   1657   u v      43      2 : 1,0,-48  
837    437   2452   u v      25      2 : 4,0,-12  
846    175  -1679   u v      47      9 : 1,0,-48  
850    549  -2749   u v      25     17 : 3,0,-16  
851    266  -1991   u v      19      7 : 1,0,-48  
852    805   3313   u v      71      6 : 1,0,-48  
854     95   1369   u v      61      7 : 1,0,-48  
858    493   2627   u v      39     11 : 3,0,-16  
860    629  -2951   u v      43     10 : 1,0,-48  
864    235  -1909   u v      27     16 : 3,0,-16  
871    420  -2461   u v      15     14 : 3,0,-16  
882    115  -1487   u v      49      9 : 1,0,-48  
893    290   2123   u v      29      5 : 3,0,-16  
893    333  -2252   u v       5     14 : 4,0,-12  
897    400  -2447   u v      25      8 : 1,0,-48  
899    675   3124   u v      28      1 : 4,0,-12  
899     74   1321   u v      37      1 : 1,0,-48  
902    665   3107   u v      41     11 : 3,0,-16  
903     23  -1052   u v      10     11 : 4,0,-12  
903    820   3443   u v      41     10 : 3,0,-16  
910    207   1873   u v      65      7 : 1,0,-48  
910      9    971   u v      35     13 : 3,0,-16  
915     16  -1021   u v       1      8 : 3,0,-16  
918    385  -2437   u v      27     17 : 3,0,-16  
923    608  -3013   u v      19     16 : 3,0,-16  
925     13   1012   u v      19      6 : 4,0,-12  
925    132  -1607   u v      11      6 : 1,0,-48  
925    876   3601   u v      73      6 : 1,0,-48  
928    123  -1573   u v      29     16 : 3,0,-16  
931    216   1931   u v      27      4 : 3,0,-16  
931    451  -2636   u v       4     15 : 4,0,-12  
938    275   2137   u v      67      7 : 1,0,-48  
940    429  -2591   u v      47     10 : 1,0,-48  
943    558  -2927   u v      31      9 : 1,0,-48  
945    209   1924   u v      23      4 : 4,0,-12  
945    472   2713   u v      59      4 : 1,0,-48  
946    861   3611   u v      43     11 : 3,0,-16  
949    714  -3301   u v      21     17 : 3,0,-16  
954     19  -1079   u v      53      9 : 1,0,-48  
962     77   1403   u v      37     13 : 3,0,-16  
975    238  -2063   u v      17      7 : 1,0,-48  
980    341  -2399   u v      49     10 : 1,0,-48  
986    245  -2101   u v      29     17 : 3,0,-16  
987    155  -1772   u v       8     13 : 4,0,-12  
987    592   3083   u v      37      8 : 3,0,-16  
989    740  -3431   u v      37     10 : 1,0,-48  
992     35  -1213   u v      31     16 : 3,0,-16  
994    435   2689   u v      71      7 : 1,0,-48  
999    119   1636   u v      22      5 : 4,0,-12  
999    670   3289   u v      67      5 : 1,0,-48