Number of tangent lines, and a circle

166 Views Asked by At

If I had a circle inscribed in a square, touching the circle at 4 points, and then need to calculate the number of secant lines on it that can reflect off the square would it be $\frac{\infty}{4}$? For example if I had a string going from one of the points to the next point then to the next point, to the original point an diamond would form inside the circle. I used secant lines, because it is based off a physics design I am making where it appears (the limit would appear to be secant, but its tangent, since the line dies after it hits that one point) it disappears right after it hits a point. How many diamonds can I inscribe, $\frac{\infty}4$? I just suggest that as an answer since the diamond has 4 points. The angle of reflection is 45 degrees, however, it is 45 degrees for every "secant"(aka tangent line in reality) of the circle. Drawing

In case its confusing thanks to how I drew it, the outside is supposed to be a perfect square, and the oval a perfect circle, and the square inside the oval a perfect diamond. The circle is a path that an electron would follow, and the square (rectangle) is a containment array. And the diamond is to minimize the number of points being touched.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On BEST ANSWER

The question is kind of vague, but I suspect you're asking the following:

Consider the billiard inside a square. How many orbits are $4$-periodic and consist of secant lines to the circle inscribed in the square?

Periodic orbits inside rectangles are a fun way to introduce yourself to the study of mathematical billiards. For a square table, an orbit returns to its starting point after $4$ reflections if and only if it starts at a $45^\circ$ angle. Here is what the clockwise orbits look like:

enter image description here

There are infinitely many such orbits, as many as there are real numbers! Your notation $\frac{\infty}4$ suggests as much, but it isn't clear what you mean by that. It would be better to ask questions with finite answers. Here's one way to do that:

Consider the billiard inside a square. Parametrize each clockwise $4$-periodic orbit with the point where it strikes the upper side of the square. What is the fraction of such orbits that consist of secant lines to the circle inscribed in the square?

With a little trigonometry, you can convince yourself that the answer is $\sqrt2-1\approx41\%$.