Ordinal arithmetic inequality

189 Views Asked by At

I have 3 ordinals $\alpha,\beta,\gamma$, $\gamma\neq 0$. Is this implication true?

$$\alpha<\beta\implies\gamma\cdot\alpha<\gamma\cdot\beta$$

I have reason to believie it is not, namely because I can't prove it by induction. (I get stuck in the inductive step as $(\gamma+1)\cdot\alpha\neq\gamma\cdot\alpha+\alpha$). Nevertheless I can't find any counterexample, so perhaps it is true.

Got any hints?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Note that $\gamma\cdot\alpha$ is isomorphic to the lexicographic ordering on $\alpha\times\gamma$.

It is very easy to conclude (via inclusion of the products) that $\gamma\cdot\alpha\leq\gamma\cdot\beta$. All you have to show now is that if $\alpha\neq\beta$ then $\gamma\cdot\alpha$ is a proper initial segment of $\gamma\cdot\beta$. That much is easy since $\beta\setminus\alpha\neq\varnothing$.

If you insist on using induction, you should do the induction on $\alpha$ or $\beta$ and not on $\gamma$. Namely, for a fixed non-zero $\gamma$, if $\alpha<\beta$ then $\gamma\cdot\alpha<\gamma\cdot\beta$. It might be the easier solution to do the induction on $\beta$.