Parametric integration negative area?

2.8k Views Asked by At

I know there is a question very similar to mine already here Why does using an integral to calculate an area sometimes return a negative value when using a parametric equation? , but I am still a bit unsure after reading the answers as to when the integral gives you a positive area and when it gives you a negative area. My text book says that the area is positive if t traces out the curve clockwise and negative for anticlockwise, however I think there is more going on with regards to whether the curve is above or below the x axis.

Since $A=\int_a^b y\frac{dx}{dt}dt$, my guess is that you get a positive answer if either the graph is above the x axis (y is positive) and the point is moving to the right (dx/dt positive) or the graph is below the x axis and the point is moving to the left. Then you get a negative answer if either the graph is below the x axis but is being traced out moving to the right, or the graph is above the x axis but is being traced out moving to the left.

Was my book wrong? Is my thinking correct?

Thank you in advance :)

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On

Your thinking is correct, and your book is not wrong.

You say that that the integral $\int_a^b y \frac{dx}{dt}\,dt$ is positive when either $y>0$ and $\frac{dx}{dt}>0$ (above the $x$-axis, moving left-to-right), or $y < 0$ and $\frac{dx}{dt} < 0$ (below the $x$-axis, moving right-to-left).
In both of these cases, the particle moves clockwise with respect to the origin.

0
On

The integral works because the assumption is that the integral is around an enclosed 2D area where the outside curve does not cross itself. Thus it really doesn't matter where the area is with respect to the origin of the space, because the sum will always be the same unless we rotate the curve, then things change. The equation works because as we march to the right (positive X), we are adding the area and as we march to the left (negative X), we are subtracting the area. Then clockwise curves will yield A greater than zero and counter clockwise will yield A less than zero.