Quotient Topology = Coproduct

1.2k Views Asked by At

Quotient topology seems to satisfy the universal property for coproducts at first glance. However, at second glance they seem to fail to fit into that frame in general since not every map passes to the quotient. So, do I miss some argument or is it simply that the quotient topology belongs to another categorical notion?

To be more precise:

The quotient topology satisfies a universal property in the sense:
A surjective map from some initial topological space induces a unique topology on its codomain s.t. whenever theres a map from the quotient space to some arbitrary topological space then it is continuous iff its composition with the quotient map is continuous. ... But this is somehow stated not in the right direction as it is given for coproducts, i.e. given a map rather from the initial topological space there exists a unique continuous map from the quotient space. This fails to exist iff the map is not constant on fibres.

3

There are 3 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

No it is not quite the same since a quotient is defined by a characteristic property while a coproduction is defined by a universal property (see discussion/answer on Proof: Categorical Product = Topological Product)

0
On

Let $X$, $Y$ be two set, $\tau$ be a topology on $X$ and $f:X\to Y$ be a function. Then $\sigma=\{V\subseteq Y:f^{-1}(V)\in\tau\}$ is the unique topology on $Y$ which satisfy the following property: For each topological space $(Z,\nu)$ and function $g:Y\to Z$, $g:(Y,\sigma)\to (Z,\nu)$ is continuos if and only if $g\circ f:(X,\tau)\to (Z,\nu)$ is continuous.

If $R$ is an equivalence relation on $X$ and $Y=X\diagup R$ and $f$ is the canonical projection, then $\sigma$ is called quotient topology.

In the language of category theory, let $\mathscr C$ be a concrete category over $\mathscr X$ with forgetful functor $|\cdot|:\mathscr C\to\mathscr X$. A morphism $f:X\to Y$ is final when ever for any object $Z$ of $\mathscr C$ and morphism $g:|Y|\to |Z|$ if $|f||g|$ lift to a morphism in $\mathscr C$ then $g$ lift to a morphism in $\mathscr C$.

If you consider the category $\mathfrak{Top}$ of topological spaces as concrete category over the category $\mathfrak{Set}$ of sets, the $f:(X,\tau)\to (Y,\sigma)$ defined above is final.

5
On

A quotient topology is best thought of as a coequalizer. In category theory, a coequalizer is the colimit of a diagram:

$X \rightrightarrows Y$

In other words, if I have two maps $f,g:X \rightarrow Y$, the coequalizer is a map $p:Y \rightarrow Z$ which is universal with respect to the requirement that $p \circ f = p \circ g$. If you think of the objects as sets, this is basically saying that we identify the images $f(x)$ and $g(x)$ in $Y$.

To explicitly connect this to a quotient map, here's a construction: Suppose $p:X \rightarrow Z$ is a surjective function. Let $U$ be the subset of $X \times X$ where $(x,y) \in U$ if and only if $p(x) = p(y)$. Give $U$ the subspace topology. Then there are two natural maps $\pi_1,\pi_2:U \rightarrow X$ (projection onto each coordinate). The claim is that, if we give $Z$ the quotient topology, $p$ becomes the colimit of the diagram:

$U \rightrightarrows X$