Solving problem with negative tcalc value. Please help.

2.6k Views Asked by At

enter image description here

Using the above data check to see if the average cholesterol determination was statistically the same or not for two labs. alpha= 0.05. Use a independent design.

enter image description here

My problem is that I got negative Tcalc. Since it cannot be negative I'm not able to finish step 5, p value. I'm not sure if I did this wrong, or is there a different way to get p value, or should I just ignore negative sign and use value of 1.5621 to finish the last step. Please help. Thank you.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Based on your experiment, I am assuming that you are using the Unpaired Student-t test.

Your answer for the t-value is correct, and the t-value can be negative - it does not have to be positive, as you have incorrectly assumed. If the t-value is negative, it means that the mean of the second dataset is greater (i.e. your Lab 2 results are greater than your Lab 1 results), and you can still calculate the p-value.

You simply evaluate the Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) of the t-distribution from $-\infty$ to $-1.5621$ (so you should not ignore the negative sign) for degree of freedom of $18$ (number of samples of Lab 1 plus number of samples of Lab 2 minus 2). You can use a table, or one of the many online calculators available on the web to carry out this operation. Let's call the result you obtain $q$. Assuming a two-tailed test, you multiply this result by 2 to obtain the p-value, so that the p-value is $2\times q$.

Supposing you had a positive t-value. You would would need to evaluate the t-distribution CDF from the t-value to $+\infty$, for the appropriate value of the degree of freedom. Calling this result $q$, the two-tailed p-value value would be $2\times(1-q)$.