Support of subobject characterized by coproducts of characters is the join of the corresponding subobjects

71 Views Asked by At

An exercise in Goldblatt's "Topoi" goes as follows, assuming the existence of set-indexed copowers of 1:

Let $\{ a_s \rightarrowtail 1 : s \in S \}$ be a set of subobjects of $1$ in $\mathcal{E}$, with characteristic arrow $\chi_s : 1 \rightarrow \Omega$ for each $s \in S$. Show that the support of the subobject whose characteristic arrow is the coproduct of the $\chi_s$'s is a join of the $a_s$'s in $\text{Sub}(1)$.

I fail to prove it even in the simple, finite case. So suppose we have $\alpha : a \rightarrowtail 1$ and $\beta : b \rightarrowtail 1$, and let $z \rightarrowtail 1 + 1$ be the pullback of $[\chi_\alpha, \chi_\beta] : 1 + 1 \rightarrow \Omega$. Now we want to prove that $\text{sup}(z) \cong a \cup b$.

Hopefully I understood what's needed right! Now, the main direction of attack I've chosen is to either show the existence of an epic $a + b \twoheadrightarrow \text{sup}(z)$ or $z \twoheadrightarrow a \cup b$ — then the uniqueness of epi-monic factorization would imply the required isomorphism.

But, no matter what I did I couldn't prove the existence of any such arrows. In fact, drawing a bunch of pullbacks and coproducts I constructed an arrow $a + b \rightarrow z$ (as the coproduct arrow of arrows $a, b \rightarrow z$, in turn arising from $z$ being a pullback and certain diagrams commuting), but I also failed to prove it's epic.

So, how do I prove at least the finite case?