trigonometric substitution in two way

74 Views Asked by At

Hi this is one of question that i have got stumbling on.

This is just simple question using trigonometric substitution.

enter image description here

i do understand the solution process.

But What i wanna know is that it uses sin for finding solution but what if use cos instead? enter image description here

my approach concluded into -arccos(x/4)+c which is say wrong answer but still if i differentiate it, it will be as same as original function in integral, which means it is also correct answer!

Guess i am missing some silly simple thing. Hope someone can help me out

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Remember that when you integrate a function you get MANY antiderivatives. That's why there is a $+C$ in answers, and it could change things. Here is video about a similar problem made by Numberphile.