Understanding proof of Continuous extension theorem for uniformly continuous function

433 Views Asked by At

I was reading, continuous extension theorem for uniformly continuous function Theorem 5.4.8 in "Introduction to real analysis by Robert G. Bartle" fourth edition In the proof, i didn't get one point.

Author has written in end of first para of proof that, if $(u_n)$ is any sequence in $(a,b)$ that converges to $a$ then $lim(u_n-x_n)=0$. So "By uniform Continuity of $f$ we have,

$lim(f(u_n))=lim(f(u_n)-f(x_n))+lim(f(x_n))=0+L=L$

How uniform Continuity of $f$ is used here?

My opinion: as $lim(u_n-x_n)=0$ hence we have $lim(u_n)=lim(x_n)= a$ (since $(x_n)$, $(u_n)$ are sequences in $(a,b)$ both converging to $a$)

So as $f$ is uniformly continuous on $(a,b)$ and hence it is continuous on $(a,b)$ hence by "Sequential criterion of continuity" we have,

$lim(f(u_n))=lim(f(x_n))=f(a)=L$ (say)

Hence, $lim(f(u_n)-f(x_n))=0$.

So that, $lim(f(u_n))=lim(f(u_n)-f(x_n))+lim(f(x_n))=0+L=L$ as required.

Is my opinion (reason) is correct? Please help.....

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

$f$ being continuous on $(a,b)$ does not mean that $f$ is continuous at $a$, because $a \notin (a,b)$. $f$ is not even defined at $a$, so there is no "$f(a)$" for those two limits to converge to.

The whole point of this theorem is that when $f$ is uniformly continuous on $(a,b)$ you can extend the domain of $f$ to include $a$ in such a way that $f$ will be continuous at $a$. You do not get to assume that the continuous extension has already happened.

Because $x_n$ and $u_n$ converge to point outside the domain of $f$, you need uniform continuity to assure $$\lim_{n\to\infty} f(u_n) - f(x_n) = 0$$

Since you cannot assume a common limit for $f(u_n)$ and $f(x_n)$, you will need to examine the definition of uniform continuity to see why else it indicates they converge to the same value.

To see that plain continuity is not sufficient, consider $(a,b) = (0,1), f(x) = \sin 1/x$.