Universal property of the algebraic closure of a field

1k Views Asked by At

At page 4 of Strom's "Modern Classical Homotopy Theory" there is a universal formulation of the algebraic closure of a field. You can read it here from google books.

Exercise 1.2a is then to convince yourself that the stated universal property does in fact characterize the algebraic closure of a field.

I cannot see why the $\bar f$ in the diagram should be unique. For example if $F=\mathbb R$ and $A=E=\mathbb C$, wouldn't the identity and complex conjugation both make the diagram commute?

Thanks in advance

P.S.: I haven't touch math in years, but always wanting to learn algebraic topology I decided to work through Strom's book for the fun of it; so I apologize if I'm missing something trivial. I tried to fish google for "universal property algebraic closure" but nothing came up.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

The algebraic closure has no universal property at all (and therefore one should rather speak of an algebraic closure). Uniqueness of extended homomorphisms fails, and this is what Galois theory is all about. (I really wonder how such statements can find their way into an advanced book on homotopy theory published by the AMS.) By the way, Grothendieck's Galois theory offers a connection between Galois theory and covering theory. The corresponding statement in covering theory then is that the universal covering space of a given space actually has no universal property (and therefore, it should not be called universal).