Using Ramanujan's Method to Prove Larger Hypergeometric Functions

378 Views Asked by At

Ramanujan had an interesting method for coming up with different hypergeometric identities. I'll provide a brief followthrough of how:

Ramanujan's Method of Morley's Identity:

Start with the product of two binomials $\displaystyle(1+u)^{y+n}\left(1+1/u\right)^x$. The coefficient of $u^n$ (denoted as $[u^n]$) is given$$\displaystyle\begin{align*}[u^n](1+u)^{y+n}\left(1+\frac 1u\right)^x & =[u^n]\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\binom xku^{-k}\sum\limits_{r=0}^{\infty}\binom{y+n}ru^r\\ & =\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\binom xk[u^{n+k}]\sum\limits_{r=0}^{\infty}\binom{y+n}ru^r\\ & =\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\binom xk\binom{y+n}{n+k}\end{align*}$$ And we also have the coefficient of $u^n$ from $(1+u)^{x+y+n}u^{-x}$$$\displaystyle\begin{align*}[u^{n+x}](1+u)^{x+y+n} & =[u^{n+x}]\sum\limits_{k=0}^{\infty}\binom{x+y+n}{k}u^k=\binom{x+y+n}{n+x}\end{align*}$$ Since they are equal, the hypergeometric identity follows soon afterward with a bit of manipulation.

Questions:

  1. Since $(1+u)^{y+n}(1+1/u)^x$ gives $_2F_1$, how would you get larger sequences, such as $_5F_4$?
  2. Using that, is it possible to prove$$_5F_4\left[\begin{array}{c c}\frac 12n+1,n,-x,-y,-z\\\frac 12n,x+n+1,y+n+1,z+n+1\end{array}\right]=\frac {\Gamma(x+n+1)\Gamma(y+n+1)\Gamma(z+n+1)\Gamma(x+y+z+n+1)}{\Gamma(n+1)\Gamma(x+y+n+1)\Gamma(y+z+n+1)\Gamma(x+z+n+1)}$$

I've spent some time, but I have no idea what to do. I believe that the RHS can be represented by$$\binom{x+y+z+n}r$$

For $r=$ something. However, I am neither sure what the LHS is, and what $r$ is.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

10
On BEST ANSWER

The following is all done in the domain of the Method of Coefficients. Some of the indexing restrictions can be alleviated if needed. The results are a little tedious but simple. It's nice to have generalized techniques on hand.


LEMMA 1: For $b>a$ and $b-a\in\mathbb{Z}$ the generating function for $\dbinom {n+ak}{m+bk}$ is

$$[t_0^n]\frac {t_0^m}{(1-t_0)^{m+1}}\left[1-\frac {t_0^{b-a}s}{(1-t_0)^b}\right]^{-1}$$

Where $s$ is the indexing variable, i.e., the $[t_0^n]$ expression is an operator transforming

$$\sum\limits_k\left(\frac {t_0^i}{(1-t_0)^j}\right)^ks^k\mapsto\sum\limits_k\binom {n+ak}{m+bk}s^k$$

PROOF:

$$\begin{align*}[t_0^n]\frac {t_0^m}{(1-t_0)^{m+1}}\left[1-\frac {t_0^{b-a}s}{(1-t_0)^b}\right]^{-1} & =[t_0^0]\frac {t_0^{m-n}}{(1-t_0)^{m+1}}\sum\limits_{k=0}^{+\infty}\left(\frac {t_0^{b-a}}{(1-t_0)^b}\right)^k s^k\end{align*}$$

For a particular $k$, we evaluate the term selected by $\left[t_{0}^{0}\right]$ (the $\operatorname{CT}(\cdot)$ type of term).

$$\begin{align*}[t_0^0]\frac {t_0^{m-n}}{(1-t_0)^{m+1}}\sum\limits_{k=0}^{+\infty}\left(\frac {t_0^{b-a}}{(1-t_0)^b}\right)^k & =[t_0^0]\frac {t_0^{m-n+(b-a)k}}{(1-t_0)^{m+bk+1}}\\ & =[t_0^0] t_0^{m-n+(b-a)k}\sum\limits_{i=0}^{+\infty}\binom {m+bk+i}{i}t_0^i\\ & =[t_0^0]\sum\limits_{i=0}^{+\infty}\binom {m+bk+i}{i}t_0^{m-n+(b-a)k+i}\end{align*}$$

Setting $m-n+(b-a)k+i=0$ gives $i=n-m-(b-a)k$, so

$$\begin{align*}\binom {m+bk+n-m-(b-a)k}{n-m-(b-a)k} & =\binom {n+ak}{n-m-(b-a)k}\\ & =\binom {n+ak}{m+bk}\end{align*}$$


LEMMA 2:

$$\sum\limits_{k=0}^{+\infty}\prod\limits_{i=0}^j \binom {n_i+a_ik}{m_i+b_ik}s^k=\left[\prod\limits_{i=0}^j\left([t_i^{n_i}]\frac {t_i^{m_i}}{(1-t_i)^{m_i+1}}\right)\right]\left[1-s\prod\limits_{i=0}^j\frac {t_i^{b_i-a_i}}{(1-t_i)^{b_i}}\right]^{-1}$$

PROOF: This is just the iterative application of LEMMA 1 since the terms are isolated.


LEMMA 3:

$$\sum\limits_{k=0}^{+\infty}\prod\limits_{i=0}^j \binom {n_i+a_ik}{m_i+b_ik}=\left[\prod\limits_{i=0}^j\left[t_i^{n_i}\right]\frac {t_i^{m_i}}{(1-t_i)^{m_i+1}}\right]\left[1-\prod\limits_{i=0}^j\frac {t_i^{b_i-a_i}}{(1-t_i)^{b_i}}\right]^{-1}$$

PROOF: This is just the dropping of $s$, or setting $s=1$ if you prefer, but that has the implication of evaluation, which is not necessary since the purpose is to generate coefficients not function values.


EXAMPLE 4: Note that

$$\begin{align*}\sum\limits_{k=0}^{+\infty}\binom xk\binom {y+n}{n+k} & =[t_0^x][t_1^{y+n}]\frac {t_0^0}{1-t_0}\frac {t_1^n}{(1-t_1)^{n+1}}\left(1-\frac {t_0^1}{1-t_0}\frac {t_1^1}{1-t_1}\right)^{-1}\\ & =[t_0^0][t_1^0]\frac {t_0^{-x}}{1-t_0}\frac {t_1^{-y}}{(1-t_1)^{n+1}}\left(1-\frac {t_0^1}{1-t_0}\frac {t_1^1}{1-t_1}\right)^{-1}\\ & =[t_0^0][t_1^0]\frac {t_0^{-x} t_1^{-y}}{(1-t_1)^n}\frac 1{1-t_0-t_1}\\ & =[t_0^0][t_1^0]\frac {t_0^{-x} t_1^{-y}}{(1-t_1)^{n+1}}\frac 1{1-t_0/(1-t_1)}\\ & =[t_0^0][t_1^0]\frac {t_0^{-x} t_1^{-y}}{(1-t_1)^{n+1}}\sum\limits_{i=0}^{+\infty}\left(\frac {t_0}{1-t_1}\right)^i\\ & =[t_0^0][t_1^0]\sum\limits_{i=0}^{+\infty}\frac {t_0^{i-x} t_1^{-y}}{(1-t_1)^{n+i+1}}\end{align*}$$

Evaluating the $t_0$ term, we have that $i=x$. Thus, we get

$$[t_1^0]\frac {t_1^{-y}}{(1-t_1)^{n+x+1}}=[t_1^0]\sum\limits_{j=0}^{+\infty}\binom {x+n+j}{j} t_1^{j-y}$$

Setting $j-y=0$ gives $j=y$.

$$\binom {x+y+n}y=\binom {x+y+n}{x+n}$$

Which is your first answer.

Remark: If wanted I can carry out the three term evaluation in the comments but it gets a little tedious. This was a good problem for me because I have been meaning to organize this for ages.