Volume of a rectangular solid

71 Views Asked by At

Compare :

Quantity A : The volume of a rectangular solid with sides of x, 2y and 3z
Quantity B : The volume of a rectangular solid with sides of 3x, y and z

Options:

A) Quantity A > Quantity B

B) Quantity A < Quantity B

C) Quantity A = Quantity B

D) Cannot be determined


My solution:

Volume = l * b * h

Quantity A : 6xyz

Quantity B : 3xyz

Now even if all x,y,z are 1, A > B

If x,y,z are fractions, still A > B

Hence, Option A) Quantity A > Quantity B


Is this solution correct ? Can l, b or h be taken as 0 for volume to be 0?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

As Hellen states in their answer, breaking up your solution into cases is not necessary. In fact, $6xyz > 3xyz$ is true for any $x,y,z >0$.

To further justify this answer, think about it this way: $2 > 1 \Rightarrow 2x>x$ if $x>0$. So for your case, $6>3 \Rightarrow 6xyz > 3xyz$, as long as $xyz >0$, which it is.

One final way to think about it is to take the difference between $6xyz$ and $3xyz$.

$$6xyz-3xyz = 3xyz, \text{which is always positive. }$$