what is the most sided sturdy regular n-polygon that can be made with lego?

299 Views Asked by At

Was puzzeling with this question:

What is the most sided regular n-polygon that can be made with lego?

  • It has to be sturdy (the polygon should stay in shape when pushed around)

  • made with the normal lego bricks (not bend or angled bricks )

  • no use should be made from non- obvious lego limitations (like the angle that bricks make under tension, the minimal angle two bricks make because bouncing against nobs no one of them.

  • mathematicly precise

For people who don't know lego:

What is the most sided regular n-polygon where :

  • all lengths are natural or rational or decided by some construction

  • all angles are right or decided by some construction

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On

The square is the only one.

To make any other regular polygon that's rigid, the sides would have to be exactly integer length to line up with another peg of a base of legos, which is arrived at by going an integer number of pegs to the right (say) and an integer number of pegs up (say). This is a Pythagorean triple with integer sides.

This means that $\sin \theta$ is rational, where $\theta$ is the exterior angle of the regular polygon. But we know that the exterior angles of regular polygons are $\theta = 2 \pi / n$ where $n \geq 3$ is the number of sides. We also know from Niven's Theorem that if $\sin ax = b$, where $a,b$ are rational, then $b = 0, \pm 1/2, \pm 1$.

The only case which gives rational $\sin \theta$ is $n=4$, which is a square.