Will changing a field affect linear dependence/ linear independence of the given vector set

559 Views Asked by At

I am given a field $F=\mathbb{Q}$ and two sets of vectors:

(i) $v_1 = (1 0 1 1)$ $v_2 = (1001)$ $v_3=(1101)$ $v_4=(1111)$

(ii) $v_1=(111-1)$ $v_2=(1110)$ $v_3=(0110)$ $v_4=(0010)$

and the question asks whether changing the field will affect the fact of whether vectors are linearly dependent or independent.

For the first set I got that they are linearly dependent and for the second - linearly independent. I tried changing the field $F=\mathbb{Q}$ to $F=\mathbb{F}_2$ and seeing what happens and it seems that the result did not change. So, I guess changing the field will not affect linear dependence/independence in these cases but I am not sure what the reasons are for that and how to explain it properly instead of using examples.

Thank you in advance!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On

This depends on what kind of "change of field" you are talking about.

1) If you have vectors from the space $\mathbb{F}^n$, and then go to a field extension $\mathbb{F'}$ such that $\mathbb{F}\subset\mathbb{F'}$, then the the linear dependence does not change. You can see this by realizing that you can express linear dependence using determinants, whose value does not depend on a field extension. An example of this are vectors over $\mathbb{Q}$. It does not matter if you go to real number, or complex, or algebraic, or anything like that.

2) But on the other hand if you just interpred the expression $(2,2,2)$ over different field, the answer is yes, it depends. Because (as @Morgan already mentioned), in $\mathbb{F}_2$, this is the zero vector. In most other fields its not. But i would say these are not really the same vectors in the beginning, just the notation happens to coincide. So in this sense, the question might not really be well posed.