(Yet) Another attempt at embedding free group on three letters inside a free group on two letters

194 Views Asked by At

This question could have been asked by several users. Here is my attempt. This could possibly be completely in the wrong direction. So I attempt to show $F(\{x,y,z\}) $ is a subgroup of $F(\{a,b\})$. My intention is to exploit the universal mapping property (UMP) (and it could be in the wrong direction but anyway I'll give it a try for reasons stated below). To begin with, we have the natural injection $i:\{x,y,z\}\to F(\{x,y,z\})$ s.t $i(x)=x,i(y)=y,i(z)=z$ and the map $f:\{x,y,z\}\to F(\{a,b\})$ given by $f(x)=a^2,f(y)=ab,f(z)=b^2$. So by UMP of $F(\{x,y,z\})$ there is a unique $\phi: F(\{x,y,z\})\to F(\{a,b\})$ (homomorphism) such that $f=\phi \circ i$ i.e $\phi(x)=a^2,\, \phi(y)=ab,\, \phi(z)=b^2$. So $F(\{x,y,z\})/ker(\phi)$ is (isomorphic to) a subgroup of $F(\{a,b\})$ and hence free.

So can we conclude from this that $ker(\phi)$ is trivial?? We will be done if this happens.

A more general question (possibly wrong) can be formulated as follows :

If $\psi : F(X)\to F(Y)$ is a surjective homomorphism between free groups, is $ker(\psi)$ trivial??

(Edit): So may be a better way to formulate the general question would be : If $F(X)$ is a free group and a factor group $F(X)/N$ is also free then does that imply the normal subgroup $N$ to be trivial?? I am having a feeling that the answer to this question is in affirmative but I am nowhere near a solution.

P.S: There could be some possible directions to prove this using fundamental groups, but my algebraic topology is quite rusty (hence didn't tag it) so I would prefer algebraic attempts. But anyways, all ideas are welcome and thanks in advance. Also I am not really good at finding counterexamples in questions related to free group, so if this question is stupid, please ignore.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On

I'll make atry to prove that $ker(\phi)=1$. Let $T=\langle a^2,ab,b^2 \rangle$. It suffies to show that $a^2,ab,b^2$ freely generate $H$. Equivalently the elements $$x=a^2(ab)^{-1}=a^2b^{-1}a^{-1},\ y=ab,\ z=b^2(ab)^{-1}=ba^{-1}$$ freely generate $H$. In any non-cancelling product of two of $x^{\pm1},y^{\pm1},z^{\pm1}$ there is always some $a^{\pm1}$ or $b^{\pm1}$. Hence no such word reduces to the identity and it follows that $H$ is freely generated by $x,y,z$.

For your second question, if $\psi: F(X)\to F(Y)$ is surjective and $ker(\psi)$ is trivial then it is an isomorphism. But I can't find a surjective homomorphism $F(s,t,w)\to F(k,l)$ which is not injective (since a group on $3$ letters is not isomorphic to a group on $2$ letters).