A general question on Galois theory: cyclotomy

96 Views Asked by At

Say we that we have a $pth$ root of unity where $p>2$ is prime. Let $E=\Bbb Q(w)$ and let $\alpha=w+w^{-1}$.

I want to figure this question out asked on a past exam:

1) Compute | E : $\Bbb Q(α)$ |, and |$\Bbb Q(α)$ : $\Bbb Q$|.

If $w$ is a primitive pth root of unity then it's Galois grouo over $\Bbb Q$ is $\Bbb Z/p \Bbb Z \cong C_{p-1}\cong C_i\times……\times C_2.$ By the Chinese remainder theorem. We see that $\alpha$ must be fixed by a transposition of the elements $w^1,w^{p-1}$. So we choose the automorphism $\phi:w\rightarrow w^{p-1}$ which is order two as $\phi(w^{p-1})=w^{p^2-2p+1}=w$. The subgroup of automorphism fixing $\alpha$ then is $\langle \phi^{p-1}\rangle \cong C_2.$ And so by Galois Correspondence $| E : \Bbb Q(α) |=2$ while |$\Bbb Q(α)$ : $\Bbb Q|=p/2$.

2) It says find the Galois group $G = Gal(E/\Bbb Q(α))$? But I did that in the first part infact I don't see another way to determine part (1) then by determining the group first, Is there ?

3)What are the isomorphisms in $G=Gal(\Bbb Q(α)/ \Bbb Q)?$ i.e. How do they act on $α?$

By the Fundamental theorem of Galois $Gal(\Bbb Q(α)/ \Bbb Q)= \cong\tfrac{Gal(E/F)}{Gal(E/Q(\alpha)}$ so $Gal(\Bbb Q(α)/ \Bbb Q)\cong C_{p-1}/C_2$.

This part confuses me, specifically because if we consider factors $C_{p-1}/C_2$ over different $p$ then we get different groups So I don't understand how this can be considered generally . Unless the question is asking you to deduce it in some other manner . In which case I Know we could say that isomorphisms in $G$ are those which fix $\Bbb Q $ but not $\Bbb Q(\alpha)$. But this a trivial.

Any advice anyone ?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Here's how to find the degree of $E$ over ${\bf Q}(\alpha)$ without finding the group.

$\omega$ satisfies a quadratic with coefficients in ${\bf Q}(\alpha)$, namely, $\omega^2-\alpha\omega+1=0$, so the degree we're looking for is either $1$ or $2$. But $\omega$ is not real, while $\alpha$ is (and, hence, all elements of ${\bf Q}(\alpha)$ are), so the degree can't be $1$, so it must be $2$.

0
On

The Galois group for the extension of Q generated by a primitive $m$-th root of unity is the group of units of Z$/m$Z. which has order $\phi(m)$ and is cyclic when $m$ is a prime number.

Your number $\alpha =w+ \bar w$ has $(p-1)/2$ distinct conjugates and so has $(p-1)/2$ as its degree. (Hint: Apply all the $p-1$ automorphisms to $\alpha$ and see that every value is repeated once)

By General Galois theory the Galois group of the upper extension is the subgroup of the Galois group fixing the intermediate field.

Now everything should be easy.