An angle bisector of length $4$ units, creates a $6$ unit line segment on the base of the triangle. What are possible integer values of its side?

57 Views Asked by At

enter image description here

What is the sum of the possible integer values of $x$

My Solution

I know that $\angle DAC \lt 90^o$ because it is an angle bisector, therefore:

$$4^2+x^2 \lt 6^2 \quad \quad 6-4 \lt x \lt 6+4$$

Combining these two I get: $$2 \lt x \lt 5 \quad x\in Z$$

But this is wrong according to the answer key. How can I solve this problem?

Edit: Inequality should have been $4^2+x^2 \gt 6^2$, though still I'm getting a wrong answer (The sum should be $24$):

$$4 \lt x \lt 10 \quad (\sum x =35)\quad x \in Z$$

2

There are 2 best solutions below

5
On BEST ANSWER

Clearly $x < 10.$ It is not hard to construct a valid figure in which $x = 9$ and all of the given conditions hold. So the question is what the minimum value of $x$ is.

Note that if $\angle ADC$ is less than a right angle, as it certainly would be if $x < \sqrt{6^2 + 4^2} = \sqrt{52},$ then $\angle ADB$ is greater than a right angle and $\lvert AB\rvert > \lvert BD\rvert.$ But since $AD$ bisects $\angle BAC,$ we have $\frac x6 = \frac{\lvert AB\rvert}{\lvert BD\rvert} > 1.$ Therefore $x > 6.$

Another way to find the same constraint is that in order for the sides $AB$ and $BC$ to intersect as shown in the figure, we require that $\angle ADC > \angle CAD,$ which implies that $x > 6.$

For good measure you can confirm that the figure can be constructed if $x=7,$ $x=8,$ or $x=9.$ But you will not find any stricter constraints than $6 < x < 10.$

So the sum of possible values of $x$ is $7+8+9=24.$

0
On

We are missing the forest for the trees. The true bound has nothing to do with the Pythagorean Theorem or the Law of Cosines.

In $\triangle ABD$, the exterior angle ADC must have a greater measure than the opposing interior angle DAB. By the bisection requirement, $\angle DAB$ is in turn congruent to $\angle CAD$.

So, in $\triangle ADC$, $\angle ADC$ must be larger than $\angle CAD$, forcing the opposite sides to have the same ordering: $CA=x$ must be greater than $DC=6$.