Calculating the expectation of types

440 Views Asked by At

A certain region is inhabited by $r$ distinct types of a species of insect. Each insect caught will, independently of the types of the previous catches, be of the type $i$ with probability $$P_i, i= 1,\dots,r$$. Calculate the mean number of types of insects that are caught before the first type 1 catch.

The solution I am looking at defines an indicator as

$$X_j = 1$$ when type j is caught before type 1

$$X_j = 0$$ otherwise

Then $$\mathbb{E}[X_j] = P\{ \textrm{type j before type 1}\} = P\{ j|\textrm{j or i}\} = \frac{P_j}{P_j + P_1}$$

But I don’t understand how

$$P\{ \textrm{type j before type 1}\} = P\{ j|\textrm{j or i}\} $$

Can someone explain how this step is correct?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

When we think about the event $X_j$, we are only interested in which is caught first: an insect of type $1$ or an insect of type $j$. And to determine which is caught first, we only need to think about the first time that a type $1$ or a type $j$ is caught (call this event $C_j$). This is because once $C_j$ happens then $X_j$ is determined, and any captures before $C_j$ don't affect $X_j$.

So at the capture $C_j$ we know that either a type $j$ or a type $1$ was captured. At $C_j$, the probability that a type $j$ was captured is $$\mathbb{P}(\textrm{type } j \textrm{ captured} \mid \textrm{type } j \textrm{ or } 1\textrm{ captured}) = \frac{\mathbb{P}(\textrm{type } j \textrm{ captured} \cap (\textrm{type } j \textrm{ or } 1\textrm{ captured}))}{\mathbb{P}(\textrm{type } j \textrm{ or } 1\textrm{ captured})}.$$ The numerator is just the probability that an insect of type $j$ is captured, so has probability $P_j$. The denominator has probability $P_1 + P_j$. Substituting this into the formula above, the probability of $X_j$ is the probability that a type $j$ was chosen at capture $C_j$, which is $$\mathbb{P}(X_j) = \mathbb{P}(\textrm{type } j \textrm{ captured} \mid \textrm{type } j \textrm{ or } 1\textrm{ captured}) = \frac{P_j}{P_1 + P_j}.$$