Coloring rooms of house obeying given rule

119 Views Asked by At

The rooms in the circular house plan shown below are to be painted using eight colors such that rooms with a common doorway must be different colors. In how many ways can this be done?

Click here to see related image

The foregiong question is solved by exclusion-inclusion.The given answer is $$8^4-\binom{6}{1}8^3 +\binom{6}{2}8^2-\bigg[\bigg(\binom{6}{3}-2\bigg)8 +2 \times8^2\bigg]+\bigg[\binom{6}{4}-\binom{6}{5}+\binom{6}{6}\bigg]8$$

I agree with given answer except for the part $$\bigg[\bigg(\binom{6}{3}-2\bigg)8 +2 \times8^2\bigg]$$

because I think that there are more than $2$ selections which will cause $8^2$

Here my marked picture for my solution

I think that selection of $(e2,e4,e6),(e1,e2,e3),(e3,e4,e5),(e1,e5,e6)$ cause $8^2$, so the answer should have been $$8^4-\binom{6}{1}8^3 +\binom{6}{2}8^2-\bigg[\bigg(\binom{6}{3}-4\bigg)8 +4 \times8^2\bigg]+\bigg[\binom{6}{4}-\binom{6}{5}+\binom{6}{6}\bigg]8$$

Am I right or missing something ?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On

Each two rooms have a common door. Therefore each two rooms have different colors. Therefore $4$ distinct colors are used for the rooms. The ways to color $4$ rooms distinctly using $8$ colors are $\binom{8}{4}*4! = 1680$ which matches your answer. Your reasoning is correct.