Construct a divergence free symmetric $(2,0)$ tensor on curved manifold withsout Riemann tensor.

119 Views Asked by At

On the flat manifold, one can construct a divergence-free symmetric $(2,0)$ tensor in this way.

  • Step 1: Define an arbitrary tensor $K^{abcd}$ with Riemann tensor like symmetry $$K^{(ab)cd}=K^{ab(cd)}=0\, , K^{abcd}=K^{cdab}.$$
  • Step 2: Define a $(2,0)$ tensor $H^{ab}$ such that $$H^{ab}=\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}K^{acbd}\ .$$ One easily check $H^{ab}=H^{ba}$ by $$H^{ab}=\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}K^{acbd}=\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}K^{bdac}=H^{ba}.$$ And it is divergence-free \begin{align} \nabla_a\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}K^{acbd}&=-\nabla_a\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}K^{acbd}+[\nabla_a,\nabla_c]\nabla_{d}K^{acbd}\\ &=-\nabla_a\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}K^{acbd}\\ \nabla_aH^{ab}&=\nabla_a\nabla_{c}\nabla_{d}K^{acbd}\\ &=0\,. \end{align} from the first line to the second line, we have used the flat condition $[\nabla_a,\nabla_c]=0$.

My question is, is there a similar method to construct a divergence free symmetric $(2,0)$ tensor on a curved manifold with a zero Ricci but allowing a non-zero Riemann tensor? And this construction should satisfy that

  • dont include the Riemann tensor and any tensor in its family (Ricci, Weyl...)

  • linear on an arbitrary tensor (any type) and its derivatives. Thus the freedom of adapting this tensor is only to set its anti/symmetry.

The above construction on a flat manifold absolutely satisfies those conditions. But, with the appearance of a curved connection, both symmetric and divergence-free conditions are broken.