Correct notation for compound conditions of random variables

106 Views Asked by At

Let $X$ be a discrete random variable, and $P(X = x)$ is its probability mass function of a binomial experiment.

If I want the probability of obtaining between 5 and 10 successes, I write $P(4<X<11)$.

However, what if I want either between 5 and 10 or between 15 and 20?

I could think of:

$P(4<X<11\vee14<X<21)$

$P(4<X<11\cup14<X<21)$

$P(X=x:4<x<11\vee14<x<21)$

How would one write it and is the use of logical operators acceptable since, in probability experiments, one uses set notation most of the time?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

In probability one usually works with events. In essence the probability operator $P$ is defined for sets, i.e. in your case we have the set $A = \{ 4 < X < 11\}$ and the set $B = \{ 14 < X< 21\}$. How the probability operator works is it takes in a set for example $$P( 4 < X < 11 ) = P(A) = P( \{ 4 < X < 11\}),$$ which is all notationally the same. Now using set theory a combination (either) of both events is the union, namely $C :=A \cup B = \{ 4 < X < 11 \} \cup \{ 14 < X < 21\}$. This new set $C$ is precisely the event when A or B happens. Hence in correct notation we have $$ P(C) = P\left(\{ 4 < X < 11 \} \cup \{ 14 < X < 21\}\right). $$ In probability theory one does not use logical operators but only events, in some more basic books it may be $\bf{defined}$ that indeed $$P\left(\{ 4 < X < 11 \} \cup \{ 14 < X < 21\}\right) = P( (4 < X < 11) \lor (14 < X < 21)). $$ Or some variation of the above but this is not typical notation. Notice that I used $\lor$ as this is the logical operator for or.