Diagonalization of total angular momentum over creation operators for an isotropic harmonic oscillator?

541 Views Asked by At

You have an isotropic three dimensional quantum harmonic oscillator so the Hamiltonian is $$ H=\frac{p^2}{2}+\frac{r^2}2 $$ If you do the creation-annihilation operator-algebra trick and define creation operator $$ a^\dagger_j=\frac{x_j-ip_j}{\sqrt{2\hbar}} $$ so that the Hamiltonian is $$ H=\hbar \left (a_1^\dagger a_1+a_2^\dagger a_2+a_3^\dagger a_3+\frac 3 2 \right) $$ so that the Hamiltonian is diagonalized by states characterized by the excitation number in each direction.

BUT if we want to compute angular momentum, we could define $3$-rotating creation operators $$ a_\uparrow^\dagger=\frac{a^\dagger_1+ia^\dagger_2}{\sqrt 2} \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ a_\downarrow^\dagger=\frac{a^\dagger_1-ia^\dagger_2}{\sqrt 2} $$ and, as $a_1^\dagger a_1+a_2^\dagger a_2=a_\uparrow^\dagger a_\uparrow+a_\downarrow^\dagger a_\downarrow$, the Hamiltonian is still nicely diagonized; moreover we also have the 3-angular momentum operator diagonal, $L_3=\hbar (a_\uparrow^\dagger a_\uparrow-a_\downarrow^\dagger a_\downarrow)$, so $L_3 \left | n_\uparrow n_\downarrow n_z \right \rangle=\hbar (n_\uparrow-n_\downarrow) \left | n_\uparrow n_\downarrow n_z \right \rangle$.

How might you similarly diagonalize $L^2$ with respect to creation-annihilation? The spherical harmonics are hellish, but Schwinger's creation operator approach is so nice and intuitive. How could we compute $L^2$ probabilities without ever integrating again?

Edit More precisely: Are there commuting operators $a,b,c$ such that $[a,a^\dagger]=\hbar$ (etc for $b$ and $c$) and the set of states defined by $$\left | n_a n_b n_c \right \rangle=(a^\dagger)^{n_a}(b^\dagger)^{n_b}(c^\dagger)^{n_c}\left | \psi_0 \right \rangle$$ form an orthogonal basis diagonalizing $H,L^2$,and $L_3$? Here $\left | \psi_0 \right \rangle$ is the ground state. How can you determine $a,b,c$ algebraically?