Do "small" and "large" numbers actually exist in an absolute sense?

304 Views Asked by At

Numbers like $(10)^{-10^{10^{10}}}$ are generally regarded as small, whereas numbers like, for example, Graham's Number, are regarded as extremely large. My question is, are these numbers simply "small" and "large" relative to "every day" numbers or are the notions of "smallness" and "largeness" absolute in some sense, meaning that "small" and "large" numbers can be objectively categorized in a meaningful mathematical way.

If the answer to this is, as I am presuming, no, that it is simply relative, then is it also true that the words "small" and "large" have no relevance in pure mathematics, where "every day" numbers are generally not privileged? What significance exactly do the symbols $>>$ and $<<$ have in pure mathematics? Or sayings like "for small $n$" or "for large $n$"?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

The symbols $\gg$ and $\ll$ don't have a formal definition. Usually they are used to compare two extremely big numbers, for example $\mathrm{Graham's \; number} \ll \mathrm{TREE}(3)$ or something like that. They are only used because someone wants to make clear that one of them is so much greater.

The numbers are indeed just small compared to everyday standards. Because when you compare $10^{-10^{10^{10}}}$ and $10^{-\mathrm{Graham's \; number}}$, you can see that $10^{-10^{10^{10}}}$ is actually much larger.

The saying [$P(n)$ for small $n$], where $P(n)$ is a proposition, formally means that there exists a $\varepsilon > 0$ such that for all $0<n<\varepsilon$ we have that $P(n)$ is true.

Similiar, the saying [$P(n)$ for large $n$], where $P(n)$ is a proposition, formally means that there exists a $M > 0$ such that for all $n>M$ we have that $P(n)$ is true.

0
On

Regarding everyday perception of number and the question of what "large" ought to mean, there is the field of Numerical cognition with many interesting experiments. E.g. when you flash a sheet with some dots for a second, people will be able to tell if there is only one dot, or two, or three. If there are three dots, people who see it for one second will not fail to claim the right number of dots that were on the sheet. "3!" But past about 7 dots people they suddenly get very bad at this game. Futher up, humans have no way or distinguishing $10^5$ form $10^6$ dots at all.