Finding cut-off point for utility function

248 Views Asked by At

OK, so apologies for the easy question, but I'm new to this! This is somewhere between elementary algebra, and beginner's game theory. The question comes from a paper I read here (see p. 193): http://home.uchicago.edu/~sashwort/valence.pdf

The following is a utility function for an individual comparing two alternatives (call them L and R). The individual, $i$, prefers L to R when:

$V_L - (x^* - x_L)^2 > V_R - (x^* - x_R)^2$

So far so good. The difficulty I'm having is figuring out how we can get from here to a cutoff rule, such that $i$ will prefer L if and only if:

$x^* < \hat{x}(x_L,x_R,v_L,v_R)$

The paper says that this can be accomplished via "straightforward algebra" to reach:

$\hat{x}(x_L,x_R,v_L,v_R) = \frac{1}{2}(x_R + x_L) + \frac{V_L - V_R}{2(X_R-X_L)}$

Sadly, for me, this algebra ain't so straightforward. If anyone could walk me through the steps to reach this point (or point out how I should approach this) that'd be great. Of course, in the SO tradition, anything more general that can help make this question more applicable to others is also very welcome.

Thanks!

--

EDIT: posted this q this morning, and have had some views but no nibbles... anyone got any suggestions? Thanks so much!

1

There are 1 best solutions below

5
On BEST ANSWER

Just to avoid cumbersome effects, use $x_*$ instead of $x^*$.

Then we have (step by step)

$V_R - (x_* - x_R)^2 < V_L - (x_* - x_L)^2 $,
$V_R - x_{*}^2 - x_{R}^2 + 2x_* x_R < V_L - x_{*}^2 - x_{L}^2 + 2x_* x_L $,
$V_R - x_{R}^2 + 2x_* x_R < V_L - x_{L}^2 + 2x_* x_L $,
$2x_* x_R - 2x_* x_L + x_{L}^2 - x_{R}^2 < V_L - V_R $,
$2x_* ( x_R - x_L) < (V_L - V_R) + (x_{R}^2 - x_{L}^2)$,
$x_* < \frac{(V_L - V_R)}{2 ( x_R - x_L)} + \frac{1}{2}(x_{R} + x_{L})$.

As somebody suggested, drop the algebraic topology tag. ;)
I hope it helps!