Help understanding a counting and probability exercise

736 Views Asked by At

I need help in trying to understand the answer to this exercise.

[Question]
A club is considering changing its bylaws. In an initial straw vote on the issue, 24 of the 40 members of the club favored the change and 16 did not. A committee of 6 is to be chosen from the 40 club members to devote further study to the issue.

How many of the committees will contain at least 3 club members who, in the preliminary survey, favored the change in the bylaws

[Answer]
$\binom{24}{3} \binom{16}{3} + \binom{24}{4}\binom{16}{2} + \binom{24}{5}\binom{16}{1} + \binom{24}{6}\binom{16}{0} = 3,223,220$

I don't completely understand the reasoning for building the equation in this way. I understand that 3 + 3 = 6 and that is why I have $\binom{24}{3} \binom{16}{3}$. But I don't understand why I have to use $\binom{16}{3}$ in the first place. Also, what is the purpose of applying both the multiplication rule and the addition rule? Could someone try to explain this please?

Thanks,

Tony

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

Think of it this way: how can you select a committee with exactly three of the special type? There's 24 to choose from, so there's $\binom{24}{3}$ ways to do that. You also have to pick three from the rest of the group and there are $\binom{16}{3}$ ways to do that, since 16 members did not favor the change. So there are $\binom{24}{3} \binom{16}{3}$ ways to choose a 6 person committee with exactly 3 of each type.

Similarly for 4,5, and 6 (since it's at least 3), so you have to sum them all up.