How can I use nine-point circle to solve this concyclic problem

165 Views Asked by At

I saw this problem on the Discord Math channel.

H is the orthocenter of △ABC. D, E and F are the foot of the altitudes of △ABC passing through A, B and C respectively. Lines EF and BC intersect at R. The line parallel to EF passing through D intersects AB and AC at P and Q respectively. M is the midpoint of BC. Prove that M, P, Q and R are concyclic.

geometric problem

Someone said that this can be proved using the nine-point circle, but I tried hard drawing figures to see things like ∠FEM = ∠BDF = ∠BAC. I also know that BM = CM = EM = FM. However, when P and M come together, I find the angle calculations hard because M is defined by a side length, and P is defined by an angle. I can't see a way without using trigonometry functions.

I've derived on my own the following basic result that the orthic triangle △DEF admits H as its incenter. I've used the result (1) in the previous paragraph.

enter image description here

I showed this by the converse of the intersecting chords theorem instead of nine-point circle. I've chosen this approach for two reasons:

  1. I've got lost in the figures while calculating angles.
  2. M is defined by a side length, so it'll be easier to calculate side lengths.

     MDDR = (0.5 BCCD) (DC + CR)      ⋯⋯ ①

We calculate CR to eliminate R from this product. I used Ceva's Theorem and Menelaus's Theorem to see that |BR : RC| = BD : DC. This gives

RC : CB = RC : |BRRC| = DC : (BDDC) = CD : (BC − 2CD)
CR = BCCD / (BC − 2CD)      ⋯⋯ ②

Substitute ② into ①:

     MDDR
= (0.5 BCCD) (DC + CR)
= 0.5 (BC − 2CD) [1 + BC / (BC − 2CD)] CD
= 0.5 [(BC − 2CD) + BC] CD
= (BCCD) CD
= BDCD      ⋯⋯ ③

Observe that B, Q, C and P are concyclic.

observation reason
CQD = ∠AEF corr. ∠s, EF // PQ
AEF = ∠ABC result (1) in above screenshot
∴ ∠CQD = ∠DBP
i.e. B, Q, C and P are concyclic. converse ofs in same seg.
BDDC = PDDQ chord thm.
MDDR = BDDC
MDDR = PDDQ
i.e. M, P, Q and R are concyclic. converse of chord thm.

Q.E.D.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On

A shorter solution:

  • $B,P,C,Q$ are concyclic, since $APQ$ is similar to $AFE$, which is similar to $ACB$
  • By the chords theorem $BD\cdot DC= PD\cdot DQ$, hence it is enough to show that $RD\cdot DM = BD\cdot DC$...
  • ... which is fairly simple by cross ratios, for instance.
4
On

Here is a way to proceed explicitly using similarities of triangles and the power of a point w.r.t. a circle. By symmetry, we may and do suppose that $\hat C$ is bigger than $\hat B$. Well, strictly bigger, else there is no $R$. The solution lives then in the following picture:

math stackexchange power of point application

Here, $ \widehat{BPQ} = \widehat{BFE} = 180^\circ-\hat C= \widehat{BCQ} $, so $BPCQ$ cyclic, giving for the power of $D$ w.r.t. the circle $\odot(BPCQ)$ $$ \tag{$1$} DP\cdot DQ=DB\cdot DC\ . $$ (We want to compute $DM\cdot DR$ and show it is equal to the above. For this, $DR$ is re-expressed using similarities to "get closer" to lengths simpler related to $\Delta ABC$.)

Let $N\in AB$ be the point making $\Delta NBC$ isosceles. Then the two green angles in the pictures are congruent, same measure $\hat C-\hat B$, leading to $\Delta DRE\sim\Delta ACN$, so $$ \tag{$2$} \frac{DR}{AC} = \frac{DE}{AN} = \frac{\displaystyle\frac{DE}{AB}}{\displaystyle\frac{AN}{AB}} = \frac{\displaystyle\frac{DC}{AC}}{\displaystyle\frac{DM}{DB}} = \frac{DB\cdot DC}{AC\cdot DM} \ . $$ Simplifying with $AC$, we get $$ \tag{$3$} DM\cdot DR=DB\cdot DC\ . $$ From $(1)$ and $(3)$ we get $DM\cdot DR=DP\cdot DQ$, so $MRPQ$ cyclic.

$\square$