How do I see that the map $X^n \to X^{n+1}$ of CW-building blocks is an embedding?

66 Views Asked by At

In his book “A concise course in algebraic topology”, May defines a CW complex inductively as being the union of increasing subspaces $X^n$, where

  • $X^0$ is discrete
  • $X^{n+1}$ is the simultaneous pushout of attaching maps $X^n \stackrel{j_\alpha}{\leftarrow} S^{n}\hookrightarrow D^{n+1}$.

I do realize that $X^{n+1}$ is the quotient of the disjoint union $X^n \sqcup\left(\bigsqcup_\alpha D^{n+1}\right)$ subject to the relations $(\alpha, s)\sim j_\alpha(s)$ for any $s\in S^n$, but I fail to see why the resulting map $\eta\colon X^n \to X^{n+1}$ into the pushout should be an embedding.

Question How do we know, at least in $\mathbf{Top}$, that $\eta$ in the pushout diagram below is an embedding if we know that each $\iota_\alpha$ is an embedding? (I've added indices to clarify which objects occur repeatedly in the colimit diagram) $$\require{AMScd} \begin{CD} S^n_\alpha @>{\iota_\alpha}>> D^{n+1}_\alpha \\ @VV{j_\alpha}V @VV{\eta_\alpha}V\\ X^n @>{\eta}>> X^{n+1} \end{CD} $$

I've tried to prove this for regular monomorphisms in general categories, but have not produced something promising in the past hour. Perhaps I'm overseeing something obvious.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

In fact we have a pushout diagram $\require{AMScd}$ \begin{CD} X^n @>{\iota'}>> X^{n+1} \\ @A{j}AA @A{J}AA\\ \bigsqcup_\alpha S^{n} @>{\iota}>> \bigsqcup_\alpha D^{n+1}\end{CD}

Unfortunately there is no way to prove that $\iota'$ is an embedding by some general category theory. It is a property of $\mathbf{Top}$ that pushouts of embeddings are embeddings. Thus, since $\iota$ is an embedding, also $\iota'$ is one.

I shall not prove this general pushout theorem here, concerning pushouts and adjunction spaces in $\mathbf{Top}$ see for example tom Dieck's "General Topology", especially Proposition (1.8.1). However, the following is very easy to prove and covers your question:

Let $A \subset Y$ be a closed subspace with inclusion $i : A \to Y$. Let $\require{AMScd}$ \begin{CD} X @>{I}>> Z \\ @A{f}AA @A{F}AA\\ A @>{i}>> Y\end{CD} be the pushout with $f : A \to X$. Then $I$ is a closed embedding.

The standard construction in $\mathbf{Top}$ gives $Z = X \cup_f Y$ which is the well-known adjunction space. Let $p : X \sqcup Y \to X \cup_f Y$ be the quotient map identifying $a = i(a) \in Y$ with $f(a) \in X$, for all $a \in A$. We have $I = p \mid_X$ and $F = p \mid_Y$. It is easy to verify that for $x \in X$ $$p^{-1}(p(x)) = \{x\} \sqcup f^{-1}(x) .$$ This show that $I$ is injective because $I^{-1}(I(x)) = p^{-1}(p(x)) \cap X = \{x\}$.

Now let $C \subset X$ be closed. Then $$p^{-1}(I(C)) = p^{-1}(\bigcup_{x \in C}I(x)) = p^{-1}(\bigcup_{x \in C}p(x)) = \bigcup_{x \in C}p^{-1}(p(x)) = \bigcup_{x \in C}(\{x\} \sqcup f^{-1}(x)) \\ = \bigcup_{x \in C}\{x\} \sqcup \bigcup_{x \in C}f^{-1}(x) = C \sqcup f^{-1}(\bigcup_{x \in C}\{x\}) = C \sqcup f^{-1}(C)$$ which is closed in $X \sqcup Y$ (recall that $A$ is closed in $Y$). Thus $I(C)$ is closed in $X \cup_f Y$.