How do I understand "time" in conditional probability and chain rule

380 Views Asked by At

P(ABCD)=P(A|BCD)P(B|CD)P(C|D)P(D)

I really do not get this to be true, the reason is that the conditional statement say: Given this has happened already (If I am correct). So it tells something about the TIME when certain events occur in relation to other events.

Example: P(A|B) = probability for A to occur given B already has occurred or (B occure BEFORE A).

P(ABCD) = The same as the intersection of all the events happening, but tells nothing about certain events happening before others.

Any comments about this that may clarify, thank you for reading?

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

So for the equation $$P(ABCD) = P(A|BCD)P(B|CD)P(C|D)P(D)$$ the RHS, reading from right-to-left, is

The probability that $D$ occurred,

times the probability that $C$ occurred, assuming knowledge (i.e., it's given that) $D\;$occurred,

times the probability that $B$ occurred, assuming knowledge that $C,D\;$both occurred,

times the probability that $A$ occurred, assuming knowledge that $B,C,D\;$all occurred.

But there is only one trial, no time sequence.

Each conditional probability represents a probability which takes into account the information provided (i.e., assuming the known occurrence of the events to the right of the vertical bar).

6
On

Yes, you are right. For two events $A$ and $B$: $$P(A\cap B)=P(A)\cdot P(B|A) \ \ (A, \ then \ B)$$ $$P(B\cap A)=P(B)\cdot P(A|B) \ \ (B, \ then \ A)$$ However, in the given formula, the information about the sequence of events is also indicated. Start interpreting from the end: $$P(C|D) \ (D, \ then \ C)$$ $$P(B|C\cap D) \ (C\cap D, \ then \ B)=(D, \ then \ C, \ then \ B)$$ $$P(A|B\cap C\cap D) \ (B\cap C\cap D, \ then \ A)=\cdots=(D, \ then \ C, \ then \ B, \ then \ A).$$