How to prove that this algebraic field extension is not separable therefore Galois.

88 Views Asked by At

Edit: Assume field K has a positive characteristic.

Let's say I have an algebraic function field $F$ over field $K$ with characteristic > 0 given by a Weirstrass equation $w(x,y)=y^2-x^3-ax-b \in K[x,y]$ in other words $F$ is the fraction field of the quotient ring $K[x,y]/(w)$. $w$ is irreducible. And lets assume that $w$ is smooth.

Now let's denote $t=y+\lambda x + \mu \in K[x,y]$. Assume that the "curve" (line) given by $V_t$ intersects $V_w$ at exactly 2 different places. Therefore I know that the polynomial $w(x,-\lambda x - \mu)$ has only 2 distinct roots, therefore it is not separable because its degree is 3.

I want to show that $F/K(t)$ is not a Galois extension. My guess would be to try to find an element of $F$ such that $w(x,-\lambda x - \mu)$ is a minimal polynomial of that element over $K(t)$. Since I know it is not separable the extension would not be separable.

I also see that $w(x,-\lambda x - \mu)=-y^2+x^2\lambda^2 + 2\lambda \mu x + \mu^2 \in F$ since $y^2 = x^3+ax+b$ in $F$.

Is it the right way? Or should I look for something else then separability. I have spent hours trying to find something but no luck.

Any hints are appreciated.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On

What is the full, complete, unabridged statement of the exercise? The question as posed is false. Consider $K=\mathbb{C}, a=-1, b=0, \lambda=0, \mu=-\sqrt{2/(3 \sqrt{3})}$. Then $w(x,y) = y^2 - (x^3-x)$ and $t(x,y) = y-\sqrt{2/(3\sqrt{3})}$ intersect in exactly two points: $(2/\sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2/(3 \sqrt{3}))}$ and $(-1/\sqrt{3}, \sqrt{2/(3 \sqrt{3}))}$. However, $F/K(t)$ must be separable, because $K(t)$ has characteristic zero, and every field extension is separable in characteristic zero.