If $D_1,D_2 \in \mathbb R ^2, D_1 \cap D_2 \neq \emptyset $ are two open discs, then $\exists D_{(a,b)} \subset D_1 \cap D_2$

120 Views Asked by At

In an exercise I have to prove the following:

Let $D_1,D_2 \in \mathbb R ^2$ be two open discs with $D_1 \cap D_2 \neq \emptyset$. If $(a,b)$ is any point in $D_1 \cap D_2$, show that there exists an open disc $D_{(a,b)}$ with center $(a,b)$ such that $D_{(a,b)} \subset D_1 \cap D_2$.


My approach:

Let $\bar D_1$ and $\bar D_2$ be the closure of the respective sets. Let $\partial(D_1\cap D_2)$ be the border of the intersection of $\bar D_1$ with $\bar D_2$. If we denote the $A=(a,b)$ then we can define: $\epsilon = \min \{\ \overline{XA},\ \forall X \in \partial(D_1\cap D_2)\}$.

If we define $D_{(a,b)}$ to be the open ball with center $(a,b)$ and with radius $\frac{\epsilon}{2}$, Then $D_{(a,b)} \subset D_1 \cap D_2$.


Is is this proof valid? If so,is this argument enough or do I need to prove or to add anything else? What other interesting ways there exists to prove this?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

For the sake of curiosity, here it is an alternative solution based on the concept of distance.

Let $(X,d_{X})$ be a metric space. Then any open ball is open as it has been proved here. Based on it, we can solve the exercise proposed.

Let us consider two open balls $B(x_{0},\delta)$ and $B(y_{0},\varepsilon)$ whose intersection $B(x_{0},\delta)\cap B(y_{0},\varepsilon)$ is not empty.

Let $y\in B(x_{0},\delta)\cap B(y_{0},\varepsilon)$. Then we conclude there exist $B(y,r_{1})\subseteq B(x_{0},\delta)$ and $B(y,r_{2})\subseteq B(y_{0},\varepsilon)$ for some positive real numbers $r_{1}$ and $r_{2}$.

Without loss of generality, we can assume that $r_{1}\leq r_{2}$. Then $B(y,r_{1})\subseteq B(y,r_{2})\subseteq B(y_{0},\varepsilon)$.

Based on the previous arguments, we finally conclude that $B(y,r_{1})\subseteq B(x_{0},\delta)\cap B(y_{0},\varepsilon)$, and we are done.

Hopefully it is useful.