Is a finite tiling of 45-45-90 triangles uniquely determined from the resulting union (up to trivial flips)?

226 Views Asked by At

Suppose I take a union of nonoverlapping $1-1-\sqrt{2}$ triangles in the plane:

enter image description here

The same shape can be tiled in another way, by flipping two triangles joined together into a square:

enter image description here

In general, are these the only such decompositions possible? That is, given two planar configurations of finitely many nonoverlapping $1-1-\sqrt{2}$ triangles whose unions are the same, are they necessarily related by some number of "square flipping" operations?

In the infinite case, this is not true, as seen by the following tilings of an infinite quadrant:

enter image description here

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

While it feels a little like cheating, the following configurations seem to provide a counter-example to the stated conjecture:

Octagon with octagonal hole, formed by eight triangles The same octagon, reflected along y-axis