Is the first part of my set theory proof correct?

47 Views Asked by At

I'm stuck with the following problem and I'm wanting to know if my proof is strong enough; and if not, what I can do to make it more rigorous. Set Theory proofs are really confusing me so apologies if I've made any steps in error.

Proof:

Take any $x,y$ such that $x \in S$ or $x \in T$, with $y = f(x), y \in B$.

Therefore, $x$ must lie in the union of $S \bigcup T$ by definition of the union; therefore, $y \in f(S \bigcup T)$ for all $x$.

Also, $y\in f(S)$ for all $x \in S$; further $y \in f(T)$ for all $x\in T$. Therefore, $y \in f(S) \subseteq f(S \bigcup T)$ and $y \in f(T) \subseteq f(S \bigcup T)$

Thus, $y \in f(S) \bigcup f(T)$ for all $x$. Therefore, $y \in f(S \bigcup T) $ and $y \in f(S) \bigcup f(T)$; therefore these two sets are equal.

Is this correct? In order to prove equality I need to go the other way; but I am unsure how to start this. Can I have someone review this and point in me the right direction to finish my proof? I understand I'm going to have to show for any $y \in f(S) \bigcup f(T)$ it also exists in $f(S\bigcup T)$ but is it really this simple?

Thank you for all responses.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

1
On BEST ANSWER

Your idea is correct, but your language is not. In order to prove that $f(S\cup T)\subset f(S)\cup f(T)$, take $x\in S\cup T$. Then you should prove that $f(x)\in f(S)\cup f(T)$, but that's easy: if $x\in S$, then $f(x)\in f(S)$ and if $x\in T$, then $f(x)\in f(T)$.

In order to prove the reverse inclusion. take $y\in f(S)\cup f(T)$. Then $y\in f(S)$ or $y\in f(T)$. If $y\in f(S)$, then $y=f(x)$ for some $x\in S$ and if $y\in f(T)$, then $y)f(x)$ for some $x\in T$. SO, $x\in S\cup T$ and therefore $y\in f(S\cup T)$.

2
On

In the first part you actually prove that $x\in S\cup T\implies f(x)\in f(S\cup T)$ which is a nothing more than a consequence of the definition of $f(S\cup T)$.


Let $y\in f(S\cup T)$. Then by definition $y=f(x)$ for some $x\in S\cup T$. If $x\in S$ then we have $y=f(x)\in f(S)$ and also - because $f(S)$ is a subset of $f(S)\cup f(T)$ - we have $y\in f(S)\cup f(T)$. If $x\in T$ then likewise we find $y\in f(S)\cup f(T)$. Proved is now $y\in f(S\cup T)\implies y\in f(S)\cup f(T)$ and this enough to conclude that $f(S\cup T)\subseteq f(S)\cup f(T)$.

From $S\subseteq S\cup T$ it follows directly that $f(S)\subseteq f(S\cup T)$. Likewise we find that $f(T)\subseteq f(S\cup T)$, and these two facts allow us to conclude that $f(S)\cup f(T)\subseteq f(S\cup T)$.

Now we proved both sides and we are ready.