Perturbation theory - Algebraic equations (Repeated roots)

1.4k Views Asked by At

Obtain a three term approximation (for $E\to 0$) of the roots of the following equation: $$x^2 + (4+E)x + (4-E) = 0$$

I understand what to do in basic cases but I've no idea what to do in this situation as I get a repeated root and obviously need two solutions. This is as far as I've got: Look for solution $$ x(E) = x_0 + Ex_1 + E^2 x_2 + \cdots$$ Substitute into equation: $$\left(x_0 + Ex_1 + E^2 x_2\right)^2 + (4+E)x + (4-E) = 0$$

$$x_0^2 + 2E x_0 x_1 + E^2 (x_1^2 + 2x_0 x_2) + 4x_0 + 4Ex_1 + 4E^2 x_2 + 4Ex_0 + 4E^2 x_1 = E-4$$

$$ O(E^0) : X_0^2 + 4X_0 + 4 = 0 \implies X_0 = -2$$ (REPEATED ROOT)

Trying to continue on anyway: $$ O(E) : 2x_0 x_1 + 4x_1 + 4x_0 = 1 \implies -4x_1 + 4x + 4x_0 = 1 \implies -7=0$$ which is clearly wrong.

Can someone please tell me the correct method for repeated roots? Any and all help is appreciated :)

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

This is actually quit subtle. At leading order you have $x_0=-2,-2$, but it all goes wrong at $O(\epsilon)$, and you get an inconsistent equation (even if you fix your slight error in the expansion). This is a sign that the ansatz you chose is not right, and we should look for a different expansion. Let's consider $x=x_0+\epsilon^\alpha x_1$. Writing out the equation gives

$$ x_0^2+2\epsilon^\alpha x_0x_1+\epsilon^{2\alpha}x_1^2+4x_0+\epsilon x_0+4\epsilon^\alpha x_1+\epsilon^{\alpha+1}x_1+4-\epsilon=0. $$

Now, we must have $\epsilon>0$ by assumption (since the $x^2$ term has an $O(1)$ coefficient the perturbation is regular), so the largest terms are $O(1)$, giving

$$ x_0^2+4x_0+4=0 $$

so $x_0=-2,-2$. Now substituting back into the expansion something very interesting happens,

$$ \epsilon^{2\alpha}x_1^2+\epsilon x_0+\epsilon^{\alpha+1}x_1-\epsilon=0 $$

the $\epsilon^{\alpha}$ terms cancel out! Now do dominant balance on this equation, we can choose to set $\alpha=1/2$, $\alpha=1$ or $\alpha=-1$. If you look at those choices, the only one we can use is $\alpha=1/2$, which gives

$$ x_1^2+x_0-1=0. $$

If you solve this you get $x_1=\pm\sqrt 3$. So, the right expansion is $x=x_0+\epsilon^{1/2}x_1+\epsilon x_2+\epsilon^{3/2}x_3+\ldots$, and continuing on you get

$$ x=-2\pm\sqrt3\,\epsilon^{1/2}-\frac{\epsilon}{2}\pm\frac{\sqrt3}{24}\,\epsilon^{3/2}+O(\epsilon^2) $$ which does converge pretty well to the right roots.

If the $\epsilon^\alpha$ terms hadn't of cancelled out, your expansion would have worked (dominant balance would choose $\alpha=1$).

Actually, the exact solution is

$$ x=-2-\frac{\epsilon}{2}\pm\sqrt{\epsilon}\sqrt{1+\frac{\epsilon}{2}} $$

and $\sqrt{1+\frac{\epsilon}{2}}$ can be expressed as a Taylor series of integer powers of $\epsilon$, so you will only get the $\epsilon^0$ and $\epsilon^1$ term in the expansion of $x$, all the other powers will be $\epsilon^{k/2}$ for integers $k$.