Proof: Zero is less than one

9.7k Views Asked by At

How can one show/prove that $0<1$?

$1$ is not actually defined to be greater than zero, but I think it can be proven. I already know that the real numbers are an ordered field and I am familiar with the field axioms and the definition of a total ordering. However I do not know how to start such a proof.

Any kind of help or advice will be really appreciated.

2

There are 2 best solutions below

4
On

$1 = 1^2$ and $x^2>0$ if $x\ne 0$.

For the last claim, the main point is that by definition of positive $x,y>0$ implies $xy>0$. This is used as follows:

If $x>0$ then $x^2 = x \cdot x > 0$.

If $x<0$ then $-x > 0 $ and so $x^2=(-x)^2 > 0$.

In turn, this follows from $(-x)y=-(xy)$, which follows from distributivity: $0 = (-x + x)y = (-x)y+(xy)$.

2
On

I'll add some details/more information to @lhf answer:

In an ordered field $K$, there is a distinguished subset $P$ such that:

(i) $\{ P,\{0\},-P\}$ is a partition of $K$,

(ii) $\forall x,y\in P$, $\; x+y\in P\;$ and $\;xy\in P$.

In particular, as $\;1=1\cdot 1=(-1)\cdot(-1)$, we see $1\in P$.

We then define a strict order relation on $K$ by setting $x>y$ if $x-y\in P$. In particular, $\;x\in P\iff x>0$.