Relation between independence of 2 random variables and their covariance

52 Views Asked by At

I know that if 2 random variables are indepedent, then E(XY)=E(X)E(Y)

IN such a case COv(XY)=E(XY)-E(X)E(Y)=0

But if Cov(XY)=0 then X and Y may or may not be independent.

But in given example, how to say 2 random variables U and V are independent or not

X~ random variable and $f(x)= 1+x, -1 <x \leq 0 ; \\ 1-x , 0<x<1, \\ 0 ,otherwise$

To check whether U=X and $V=X^2$ are independent or not

My attempt:

$E(x)=0 = E(x^3)$

$E(x^2)=1/6$

$E(UV)=E(x^3)=0$

$E(x)E(X^2)=0$ and also $Cov(U,V)=0$

My doubt is whether U and V are independent or not as i am getting E(UV)-E(U)E(V)=0 and also Cov(U,V)=0

1

There are 1 best solutions below

3
On

If zero covariance does not imply independence, then why are you trying to calculate the covariance to show independence? That won't tell you anything useful. It's like saying that showing a number $x$ is positive does not imply that it is even, but then you are trying to prove $x$ is positive and wondering why this doesn't prove $x$ is even.

Instead, $U = X$ and $V = X^2$ clearly cannot be independent, because knowledge of $X$ immediately tells you the value of $X^2$. This is trivial.