Relationship between incenter and circumcenter

2.9k Views Asked by At

Let $ABC$ be an acute triangle with circumcenter $O$ and incenter $I$. Points $E$, $M$ lie on $AC$ and $F$, $N$ on $AB$ so that $BE \perp AC$, $CF\perp AB$, $\angle ABM = \angle CBM$ and $\angle ACN = \angle BCN$. Prove that $I$ lies on $EF$ if and only if $O$ lies on $MN$.

I honestly can't make any progress. I tried playing around on geogebra but it seems like when I get a configuration where $O$ and $I$ are on the desired lines, $O$ and $I$ stay on these lines as I move $A$ around the circumcenter...

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

Here is a "synthetic" solution with metric arguments:

We will show both conditions are equivalent with $\cos B +\cos C=\cos A$.

Condition 1: $O$ lies on $MN$. Let $\delta (P, XY)$ be the distance from point $P$ to line $XY$. Notice that since $M,N$ are the feet of the angle bisectors that $\delta (M, AB) + \delta (M, AC) = \delta (M, AB) = \delta (M, BC)$.

Meanwhile, $\delta (N, AB)+\delta (N,AC) = \delta (N,AC)=\delta (N,BC)$.

Since distances from points to lines form linear functions, the function $\delta (P, AB)+\delta (P, AC)-\delta (P, BC)$ must be zero for any point $P\in MN$, because it is zero for $P=M,N$.

Then if $O$ lies on the line, $\delta (P, BC)= R\cos A, \delta (P, AC)=R \cos B, \delta (P, AB)=R\cos C$ which implies $\cos B+\cos C=\cos A$.

Condition 2: $I$ lies on $EF$.

Remark that quadrilateral $BCEF$ is cyclic. Let $X$ be a point on segment $EF$ with $BF=XF$. Note that $\angle BXF = 0.5( \angle BXF + \angle FBX) = 0.5(\angle AFX) = 0.5 \angle ACB = \angle ICB$. This implies that quadrilateral $BXIC$ is cyclic.

As a result, since $\angle IBC=0.5\angle B$, we deduce $\angle IXC = 0.5\angle B$. Then since $\angle XEC = 180-\angle AEF = 180-\angle B$, we deduce that $\triangle XEC$ is isosceles so $XE=EC$.

Then $EF = EX+FX = EC+BF$. But $EF=a \cos A, EC = a \cos C, BF = a \cos B$ so we deduce $\cos A =\cos B + \cos C$ as desired.

Thus the two conditions are equivalent.