Simply connected vs open connected

6.2k Views Asked by At

Stewart - Calculus


In the red box, is that really 'a stronger' rather than 'an additional' ?

I mean, if simply-connected implies open connected, then why do we have open simply-connected in Theorem 6?

Otherwise, what is meant by stronger? I thought that meant simply-connected implies open connected.

Note: My knowledge on topology or whatever you call it is mainly limited to 1D.


enter image description here


enter image description here


enter image description here


1

There are 1 best solutions below

4
On BEST ANSWER

When we assume that the region is simply connected, you're right that we're just making an additional assumption about the region. The author calls this condition 'stronger' because it's harder to satisfy. There are plenty of open, connected regions which fail to be simply connected.

We do, however, have to include the word open in Theorem 6. Not all simply connected regions are open.