True or False: A line is a parabola.

891 Views Asked by At

It is known that a line is a degenerate parabola. But if asked as above, what is the better answer?

Context: This question appeared on a quiz recently given in our Precalculus class. It is not clear to me and my classmates if the answer is True or False. Our book says the following. enter image description here

3

There are 3 best solutions below

0
On

No, in almost all contexts. Very occasionally you might encounter a family of parabolas one of which is degenerate; then it might be acceptable.

If you have been asked this question, tell us the context.

0
On

The parabola is $y^2=4ax$, if you put $a=0$, it becomes a line $y=0$. So one may say that a line is a parabola whose length of latus-rectum is zero. This is how a parabola degenerates to a line. A line is the thinnest parabola.

1
On

Consider the parabola $~y=a~x^2~$.

All parabolas can be rotated and translated to arrive at this form. Hence this equation covers all possible parabolas in the $2$D plane for the purpose of this problem.

Now, for a straight line to exist, we should be able to find a point where $~\frac{dy}{dx}~$ does not change.

But, $~\frac{dy}{dx}=2ax~$

The derivative is different for all points on the parabola since it is dependent on $~x~$ and there is only one $~y~$ for each $~x~$.

So we can conclude that the statement is false.

**************-

see https://www.quora.com/How-do-you-prove-that-there-are-no-straight-lines-in-a-parabola