Turing's Symmetries

73 Views Asked by At

In Alan Turing's classic paper on the Chemical Basis of Morphogenesis, the following bilateral and left-right symmetries are defined as follows:

enter image description here

Might be an misunderstanding of English from my side, but I can't really visualize this non-parallel upright strokes and what makes it different from the bilateral symmetry. This is what I'm imagining

enter image description here

Is that what he means? He goes further to define P- and F-symmetries, which is also a bit confusing with the 'coal scuttle' example:

enter image description here

Any suggestions on where I could learn more about this? Are there more mathematically "better" ways of defining such types of symmetries?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On

Imagine looking through the $P$ that's closer to you (colored in green below) and right at the $P$ that's on the far side (in red). Namely, you line of sight roughly aligns with the straight line formed by connecting the two $P$s.

enter image description here

Apologies for the choice of colors. I tried to make the green $P$ thicker to represent that it is closer to your eyes.

The red $P$ is an image of the green (thicker) $P$ via moving along the surface of cylinder (equivalent to rotating in space).

The upright stroke (the "vertical" bar when P is written this way) of one is not parallel to the other in the 3-dim Euclidean space.


I don't know how to produce using Mathjax the diagram with two $P$s. The all-powerful Detexify returns nothing.