Two metrics producing different ordering of distances

249 Views Asked by At

What is it called when two metrics disagree on the order of distances? That is, there exists two pairs $\left( \{x_1,y_1\} , \{x_2,y_2\} \right)$ such that

Metric A : $d(x_1,y_1) > d(x_2,y_2)$

Metric B : $d(x_1,y_1) < d(x_2,y_2)$

Is there a stricter set of metrics that preserve order among metrics within that set?

Example:

WLOG assume both start at the origin and destination is either $P=(20,15)$ or $Q=(24,10)$. And $d_p$ is the p-norm. (1: Taxi-cab distance, 2: Euclidean)

$d_2(P) = 25 \qquad d_2(Q)=26$

$d_1(P) = 35 \qquad d_1(Q)=34$

According to $L_2$ metric, $d_2(P)<d_2(Q)$, but $L_1$ has $d_1(P)>d_1(Q)$. Which point is closer depends on the metric. (I knew the distances would numerically be different, but thought metrics preserved the order)

Is there a name for this property? Is there a class or metrics which preserve ordering?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On

I would describe the two metrics as "not comparable", i.e. neither one is consistently less than or equal to the other. But I don't think this is common language, as I've not seen any math that worries about this particular property of metrics.

And while I don't think this answers your particular questions, I will mention that taking the max of two metrics, i.e. defining $d_{max}(x,y) = \max \{d_1(x.y), d_2(x.y)\}$ is a very common construction when you are concerned with two different properties simultaneously. E.g. $x_n \rightarrow x$ w.r.t. $d_{max}$ if and only if $x_n \rightarrow x$ w.r.t. $d_1$ and $x_n \rightarrow x$ w.r.t. $d_2$. Also note that $d_1 \le d_{max}$ and $d_2 \le d_{max}$. This gives the set of metrics a natural structure of an upper semilattice, and a class of metrics that preserve ordering that you asked about would be a totally ordered sub-lattice of that lattice.