Two unusual approximations in right triangle trigonometry

107 Views Asked by At

iN the 1780 textbook The Resolution of Triangles, by Hugh Worthington’s, the following approximation to solve the case of a right triangle when the angles and one side is given:

(1) "In any right angled triangle, as $ CAB$, let $ \alpha$ be the lesser angle in degrees. Then $\frac{57.3}{\alpha} + \frac{3\alpha}{1000} : 1 = AC : AB$, nearly"

where $AC$ and $AB$ are the hypotenuse and the opposite side to the angle $\alpha$, respectively. Also,

(2) $ 1 : 1 - \frac{1\frac{1}{2}\alpha^2}{10000} = AC : BC $

where $BC$ is the adjacent side.

The question is: how to derive the approximations (1) and (2)? The numerator of the first fraction in (1) is $57.3$. It should be related to $180/\pi \approx 57.29...$

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On

Using $\frac{180}{\pi}$ for $57.3$, rewriting (1) so that $\alpha$ is in radians, and noting that $AC:AB = \csc \alpha$, one gets $$\frac{3 \left(\pi \left(60000+\frac{180 \alpha }{\pi }\right)^2\right)}{1000\pi\cdot\frac{ 180 \alpha }{\pi }} = \frac{1}{\alpha} + \frac{27}{50\pi}\alpha.$$ The MacLaurin series for $\csc\alpha$ is $$\frac{1}{\alpha }+\frac{\alpha }{6}+\frac{7 \alpha ^3}{360}+\frac{31 \alpha ^5}{15120}+\frac{127 \alpha ^7}{604800}+\frac{73 \alpha ^9}{3421440}+O\left(\alpha ^{11}\right),$$ and $\frac{1}{6} \approx 0.1666667$ while $\frac{27}{50\pi}\approx 0.171887$.

Note that just $\frac{1}{\alpha}$ is a pretty good approximation for $\alpha$ small. Since $\alpha$ is the smaller angle, it should be a decent approximation all by itself. In the graph below, $\csc\alpha$ is the blue line, the approximation in (1) is the orange line, $\frac{1}{\alpha}$ the green line, and $\frac{27}{50\pi}\alpha$ the red line. enter image description here

The second equation is similar; rewriting for $\alpha$ in radians and looking at the Maclaurin series of the resulting LHS and of $\sec\alpha$ shows that the first two terms are pretty close to each other.