What is the cartesian equation of an ellipse whose center is $(3,2)$ , whose rightmost vertex is $(5,7)$ and whose semi minor axis $3$ units long?

82 Views Asked by At

Desmos construction corrected

Briefly, my questions deals with the shifting terms that have to be applied in order to move the blue ellipse to the purple one :

enter image description here

https://www.desmos.com/calculator/gise9qcyfz

The givens of the question are :

(1) the ellipse the equation of which is researched is centered at $C_f = (3,2)$.

(2) its right vertex is $V_f = (5,7) $

(3) the length of its semi minor axis is ( arbitrarily) $3$ units

(4) this ellipse is the result of rotating and translating an original ellipse that is in standard orientation and in standard position ( hence, with its major axis on the X axis , and its center at $(0,0) ) $.

Step 1 : equation of the original ellipse in standard orientation and in standard position

Let $S_M$ be the length of the semi major axis; we have : $S_M = \sqrt {(5-3)^2 + (7-2)^2}$ ( because rotation and translation preserve length).

Equation of the original ellipse : $\large \frac {x^2} { (S_M) ^2} + \frac {y^2} {3^2} =1$

Step 2 : equation of the rotated ellipse whose major axis will be parallel to the major axis of the final ellipse

Let $R$ be the angle by which the ellipse is rotated; we have : $R = \arctan \bigg{(} \frac {7-2} {5-3} \bigg {)}$.

Applying the rotation of axis formula , we get :

  • $X(x,y) = x \cos(R)+ y \sin(R)$

  • $Y(x,y) = y \cos(R) - x \sin(R)$

  • and finally, for the rotated ellipse : $\large \frac { X(x,y)^2 } { (S_M)^2 } + \frac { Y(x,y)^2 } {3^2 } =1 $

Step 3 : shifting the rotated ellipse in order to get the final ellipse.

What remains to be done is to find the shifting terms $ h$ and $k$ in the final equation :

$$\large \frac { (X(x,y) -h)^2 } { (S_M)^2 } + \frac { (Y(x,y) -k)^2 } {3^2 } =1 $$

If I am correct, these shifting terms " operate" , so to say, in the rotated coordinate system , with

  • new X axis :$ y = \tan (R) x $
  • new Y axis : $y = (-1/ \tan(R))x $

Let $\gamma$ be the angle point $C_f = (3,2)$ makes with the new ( rotated) Y axis .

enter image description here

We have $ \gamma = \arctan (2/3) + ((\pi/2) -R)$.

With $D= \sqrt {2²+3²}$ the distance from $C_f$ to $O$ , the ( unchanged) origin, the new coordinates of $C_f$ are $ (h, k) = ( D \sin\gamma , D \cos \gamma)$.

So applying the new coordinates of $C_f$ as shifting terms , it seemed to me that I should have ( for the final ellipse) :

$$\large \frac { (X(x,y) -h)^2 } { (S_M)^2 } + \frac { (Y(x,y) -k)^2 } {3^2 } =1 . $$

However, the equation that, apparently works requires not a minus $k$ but a plus $k$ :

$$\large \frac { (X(x,y) -h)^2 } { (S_M)^2 } + \frac { (Y(x,y) +k)^2 } {3^2 } =1 . $$

Since $h$ and $k$ are both positive numbers , should not the displacement to the right and the displacement in the direction of the positive ( new) Y axis require a minus sign in both cases?

Note : I observe the same phenomenon if I directly apply as shifting terms the coordinates of $C_f$ in the original non rotated coordinate system , namely $(3,2)$.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

1
On

I don't really get how you computed $\gamma$, but I imagine the root of your problem is the fact that $(h,k) = (D\cos \gamma, D\sin\gamma)$ expand into $$\cos \gamma = \cos \left ( \frac{\pi}{2}+\arctan(2/3) - R \right )=-\sin\left (\arctan(2/3) - R \right),$$ meanwhile $$\sin \gamma = \sin \left ( \frac{\pi}{2}+\arctan(2/3) - R \right )=\cos \left (\arctan(2/3) - R \right).$$ So that $$\left ( Y-\left | k \right | \right )^{2}$$ should actually be $$ \left ( Y-\left(-\left | k \right | \right) )^{2}=(Y+\left | k \right | \right )^{2}.$$

PS: Please work on your notation. You can stick to complete abstraction replacing all constants with variables, so you won't have as many problems with +/-'s. You can also give the variables you provided more meaningful "names". The post was very difficult to comprehend "as is".