What is the formula of this angle?

262 Views Asked by At

enter image description here

Place three congruent equilateral triangles as in figure (the point on side is midpoint of side).

Mark angle is $89.9..$ degree not $90$ degree. It is very strange.

My question. What is the formula of this angle?

1

There are 1 best solutions below

2
On BEST ANSWER

enter image description here

Putting some labels on the vertices of your triangles, we have congruent equilateral triangles $\triangle ABC,$ $\triangle DEF,$ and $\triangle GHI.$

For simplicity, assume each side of each of these triangles has length $1.$ This does not change the angles but makes it simpler to write the other lengths in the figure.

We then have $AE = \frac12$ and $EP = \frac12\sin 60^\circ < \frac12.$

Since $\triangle DEP$ is a right triangle we have $\angle EDP = \arcsin\frac{EP}{DE} = \arcsin EP.$ Since $EP < \frac12$ we also have $\angle EDP < 30^\circ$ and therefore $\angle HDQ = 60^\circ + \angle EDP < 90^\circ$ and $\sin \angle HDQ < 1.$

We then have $DH = \frac12$ and $HQ = \frac12\sin \angle HDQ < \frac12.$ Therefore $\angle HGQ = \arcsin\frac{HQ}{GH} = \arcsin HQ < 30^\circ$ and $\angle IGD = 60^\circ + \angle HGQ < 90^\circ.$

In order for one side of an equilateral triangle to be at an exact right angle from the horizontal line that extends side $AB,$ the third vertex of the triangle has to be exactly a distance $\frac12$ from the line $AB.$ But if that vertex is the midpoint of a side of another congruent triangle, and that side does not make exactly a right angle with the line $AB,$ then that vertex will be at a distance less than $\frac12$ from line $AB.$

However, with each triangle that we add to the figure in this way, the third vertex is a little father from line $AB$ than the third vertex of the last triangle, therefore the angle of the side with line $AB$ is a little closer to a right angle and the distance of its midpoint from line $AB$ is even closer to $\frac12$.

We could keep on adding triangles to the figure like this indefinitely, and the angle between the side and line $AB$ would get closer and closer to a right angle but can never be exactly equal to a right angle. You may find it curious that after the third triangle we are already within one tenth of a degree from a right angle, but we would have gotten that close eventually and we will get much closer if we add a fourth triangle to the figure.

Now suppose we have a figure with $n$ triangles put together this way, and let $h_k$ be the distance from line $AB$ to the third vertex of the $k$th triangle. That is, $\triangle ABC$ is the first triangle, so $h_1 = 0.$ The $h_k$ terms are a series with $h_2 = EF$ and $h_3 = HQ.$ Let $\theta_k = \arcsin h_k.$ In general, $h_{k+1}$ is half the sine of an angle that is $60$ degrees greater than $\theta_k.$ By the angle addition formula for sines, $$ h_{k+1} = \frac12\sin\left(60^\circ + \theta_k \right) = \frac12\left( \sin 60^\circ\cos\theta_k + \cos 60^\circ\sin\theta_k \right) = \frac{\sqrt3}{4}\sqrt{1 - h_k^2} + \frac14 h_k.$$ So $h_2 = \frac{\sqrt3}{4}$ and $$ h_3 = \frac{\sqrt3}{2}\sqrt{\frac{13}{16}} + \frac14 \frac{\sqrt3}{4} = \frac{\sqrt{39} + \sqrt3}{16} \approx 0.49857.$$ So $$ \angle IGD = 60^\circ + \arcsin\left(\frac{\sqrt{39} + \sqrt3}{16} \right) \approx 89.9051428675277^\circ.$$

Note that we could use the angle addition formula to keep going with a fourth triangle, a fifth triangle, and so forth. The lengths $h_k$ are always algebraic numbers, but of course at the end you have to take an arc sine to get the final angle.