What is the meaning of null regression coefficients

327 Views Asked by At

I have real data $x(t)$ which I model using the linear regression model: $\displaystyle f(t)= \sum_{i=0}^n c_i \phi_i(t)$, where $c_i$ are the regression coefficients I'm trying to find and $\phi_i(t)$ are a basis function (I chose Legendre Polynomials for their orthogonality).

I noticed something strange I couldn't explain i.e. when I fix $n=1$ for my model I get $\hat{c}_0, \hat{c}_1$, normal! Then when I fix $n=2$ for my model I get $\hat{c'}_0=\hat{c}_0, \hat{c'}_1=\hat{c}_1, \hat{c'}_2=0$ (Seems like $n=2$ didn't add anything to the data modeling!)

What is more strange is that when I fix $n=3$, I get $\hat{c''}_0, \hat{c''}_1, \hat{c''}_2, \hat{c''}_3$ that are completely different (no $\hat{c''}_2=0$)

Does anyone understand what is happening here?

This also happens for other even index coefficients $c_4, c_6, \dots$ i.e. when they are the latest regression coefficient in my model they are null but when I add another odd index coefficient they are not. Also I noticed that the coefficient values I obtain are high (as if to indicate an overfitting!)

1

There are 1 best solutions below

7
On

The Legendre polynomials are orthogonal, but your regression results (by changing) show that their values on your data have nonzero covariance.

If $f(t)$ is odd that would explain the odd/even pattern with the $c_i$, where the even degree $c_{2n}$ contribute nothing on their own, but are involved in isolating the contribution of odd powers of $x$.