What is the relationship between the final concentrations of alcohol in the alcohol jug and water in the water jug?

1k Views Asked by At

Question

Answer1

Answer2

If the mixture is being poured back into the jug with water, then how can the jug with water also contain ${\frac {V}{V+Q}}$. I would assume that when the diluted alcohol is poured into the jug with water, that water jug will contain ${\frac {V}{V+Q}}$ plus water.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

You must make the distinction between the concentration and the volume. Let's take a look at a numerical example to see that the description is correct.

Suppose we start with $200$ mL of pure alcohol in one jug and $200$ mL of pure water in the other. ($V=200$ mL)

Now, we pour $50$ mL of water into the alcohol jug. This leaves $150$ mL of water in the water jug, and now we have $250$ mL of liquid in the alcohol jug. In particular, the liquid in the alcohol jug is a mix of $50$ mL of pure water with $200$ mL of pure alcohol. That is, the alcohol's concentration is now $$\frac{200}{200+50}=\frac{200}{250}=80\%$$ (and $20\%$ water) even though the same volume of alcohol is in the container as before.

Now, we mix it thoroughly, meaning that we are to assume that for any volume $V_0$ of fluid taken from the alcohol jug, it will be $80\%$ alcohol and $20\%$ water (as will the remaining volume in the jug). So, when we pour $50$ mL of mix back into the water jug, we are left with $200$ mL of the $80\%$ alcohol mix in the alcohol jug, and have poured a mix that is $40$ mL alcohol and $10$ mL water into the water jug. That amounts to a total of $160$ mL water and $40$ mL alcohol, so the fluid now in the water jug is $$\frac{160}{160+40}=\frac{160}{200}=80\%$$ water (and $20\%$ alcohol).