Alice Term Paper Question

1.2k Views Asked by At

Alice searches for her term paper in her filing cabinet. which has several drawers. She knows that she left her term paper in drawer $j$ with probability $p_j$ > $0$. The drawers are so messy that even if she correctly guesses that the term paper is in drawer $i$. the probability that she finds it is only $d_i$ . Alice searches in a particular drawer. say drawer $i$ . but the search is unsuccessful. Conditioned on this event, show that the probability that her paper is in drawer $j$, is given by \begin{cases} \cfrac{p_j}{1-p_id_i} & \text{if $j \neq i$},\\ \cfrac{p_i(1-d_i)}{1-p_id_i} & \text{if $j = i$} \end{cases}

I followed that approach, and I couldn't find anything. Sorry for grammatical mistakes.

1

There are 1 best solutions below

0
On BEST ANSWER

Let $F$ be the event that she fails to find the paper in drawer $i$, and $I$ be the event that the paper is in drawer $I$.

Then $p(F|I)=p_i(1-d_i)$ and $p(F|\text{not }I)=1-p_i$. Hence $$p(I|F)=\frac{p(F|I)}{p(F|I)+p(F|\text{not }I)}=\frac{p_i(1-d_i)}{p_i(1-d_i)+(1-p_i)}=\frac{p_i(1-d_i)}{1-p_id_i}$$ So the prob that it is not in drawer $i$ after her search of that drawer is $$1-\frac{p_i(1-d_i)}{1-p_id_i}=\frac{1-p_i}{1-p_id_i}$$ Clearly her search of drawer $i$ does not affect the ratios of the other probabilities to each other, so the probability of finding it in drawer $j\ne i$ becomes $$\frac{p_j}{1-p_id_i}$$